Interesting discussion indeed. Good, valid points on both sides of the debate. I still like the original rule of one thread per girl, and with that in mind, I prefer one section for all reviews.
I know better - but most times when I do search for a review, I still use the search box in the top right corner of every page. I don't go to the relevant section and search the forum. It's only an extra step or two, I know, but my point was about streamlining, and I am always looking for more efficiency and fewer steps, even if it means breaking the status quo. Just my nature.
Can we live with the present system? Of course! Regardless, transitioning to one section only would be a difficult task, requiring significant effort, and there are frankly not enough Mods to do that. No straightforward join mechanism to identify common SPs across both sections, so it would be highly manual. Oh well. An interesting gedanken.
To some posters' suggestions of an Indy section, I strongly disagree. On the same grounds of one thread per SP. Sex is sex. The SP is the SP, regardless of agency affiliation or lack thereof. With the same argument for when SPs change agencies, still the same girl, there shouldn't be a new thread. 'Indy' is just the new agency. If you want to point out differences, write it in the review.
