Should outcall and incall threads for all SPs be merged into one thread
- Thread starter wolfie7
- Start date
Agreed cloud, and often the experience in incall and outcall is quite different for many providers, no point bunching them together.
I tend to agree with Wolfie. People don't follow the rules anyway. For example, i know of at least one indy whose clients are mostly incalls. Yet, when they review her, they review her in the outcalls section since there isn't an incall thread for her. Is it misleading? No, not really. But many people who strictly do incalls may (and likely) miss out on her since the only section they check for reviews is the incalls section. Myself, i rarely check the incalls section since i mostly do outcalls.
That would be up to one brave soldier to clear the way and apply the allowed rules by starting that damsel a thread in the incall section.
So yeah umm, back to isabellas outcalls :thumb:
So yeah umm, back to isabellas outcalls :thumb:
I don't think there should be. It's a relic from when Montreal rarely had any incalls, at least from the top agencies.
Are there separate sections for Incall Escort Agencies and Outcall Escort Agencies? No. And there shouldn't be.
Does physical appearance and services offered change as a result of location??
I hope not. I've seen Zoe incall and outcall - no difference. I've seen Chloe incall and outcall - no difference. I don't even remember if I posted to the correct threads for those reviews. Actually, Chloe, definitely not. If you want to point out experience differences, write it in the review. (BTW, I rarely see anyone do that.) You don't need a separate section to call that out.I'm not trying to hurt SPs here. In fact, I think it would help. I'm just trying to streamline the review search experience for hobbyists with the suggestion. Sometimes, one thread is posted to way more often than the other, and a new guy who doesn't know any better may never realize there was a second set of reviews, with possibly a useful nugget of information relevant to him.
My 2 cents. BTW, this is an interesting discussion. We should probably move to the The Lounge, as these are not relevant to Isabella's review...
My 2 cents. BTW, this is an interesting discussion. We should probably move to the The Lounge, as these are not relevant to Isabella's review...[/QUOTE]
I agree with wolfie7, everything from #2 to now should be moved to the lounge and we can reflect our opinions there, cause nothing we are writing has to do with Isabella and her services per say, and leave room for comments and reviews. Thank you.
Thor Jr
I agree with wolfie7, everything from #2 to now should be moved to the lounge and we can reflect our opinions there, cause nothing we are writing has to do with Isabella and her services per say, and leave room for comments and reviews. Thank you.
Thor Jr
This is my take on this subject and i took this out of one of my passages i recently sent and i quote: As for the merging of threads, my take is if a lady goes from one agency to another , yes merge them, but when they cross over to an Indy status, let them start fresh and give them the Indy glamour.
The girls change names from agency to agency, by very rarely do indies change their names.
I am sure we all have our difference of opinions and with good reasons, so lets hear it...
Nothing here says we cant write our review of this lady who is now an Indy and happen to mention that we met Tracy when she was with ABC agency and we had a great time and the service has gotten even better or that her service has not improved or is worse now.
So, inquiring minds want to know, what do you think?
Thor Jr
The girls change names from agency to agency, by very rarely do indies change their names.
I am sure we all have our difference of opinions and with good reasons, so lets hear it...
Nothing here says we cant write our review of this lady who is now an Indy and happen to mention that we met Tracy when she was with ABC agency and we had a great time and the service has gotten even better or that her service has not improved or is worse now.
So, inquiring minds want to know, what do you think?
Thor Jr
I totally agree with what Wolfie said in his last post. There is no longer a valid reason to have two separate sections to review or discuss the same girl just because she either received or saw the client at his hotel or residence. I doubt very much that the service or experience changes much, if it all. As he mentionned, incall in Mtl is no longer a rarity. If every sp who did both would be reviewed in both sections, it would be a free for all. One section only for the sps being reviewed would keep things simple and easier to access. It would be more organized. For myself, it would be much more preferable.
Agree with Wolfie: incall-outcall threads for the same SP should be merged into 1 thread in a general review sections that would encompass both incall and outcall reviews. With more and more agencies and indy SP's providing both in and out service, ensuring that all the info is in the same place will make it easier for us to have access and make enlightened and informed decisions
If we have to live with TWO sections (incall & outcall), one review thread in each section should be mandatory if the lady offers both in & out, not the opposite like in the merb rule.
And if possible, with a link in the first post that join both thread.
It is not annoying for me to have two threads for the girl cause when I do a search for a lady, I will find her no matter what section she has been reviewed in.
BUT, when I just browse into merb sections, I go in the INCALL section only to see the new posts (unread). very very rarely I visit the outcall section...
Since I do incall only, I like to skip the outcall only reviews and get only the posts for my interest.
So, the actual rules tend to mislead me in my browsing when a girl offers both in & out but is reviewed in only one section...
I will find the review if I'm doing searches but not always if i'm just browsing.
So I tend to agree that only one section should exist with one thread per lady.
However, this is interesting to know if the meeting happened incall or outcall. If the lady offers only incall or outcall or both...
I certainly do not want to read reviews of outcall only ladies. Lost of time
But I think at the beginning, we'll have tons of questions after a review: Was it incall or Outcall.
And I also think people may get used to it and start writing this information at the very beginning of their review posts.
So, in short, with the ACTUAL setup.
When I want to MEET a girl, I do seach with Merb search engine. I usually go into the advance search, and select TITLE ONLY and put the lady's name as the keyword. The section is not important in that case, I'll find her reviews no matter where it is...
When I just want to browse:
First I often use the "what's new" in the menu at the top. So here again, section is not really relevant, I'll click on what caught my interest.
Second, I might not go through all items in the "What's new" especially if there are many pages, then I go see directly the new posts in the section of my interest, INCALL section and LOUNGE.
So, really, I can live with the actual setup, but I may miss informations I'd like to know, ie, girls that are now offering incall but reviewed in the outcall only because of actual merb rules... But happily, it is more tolerated having two threads now.
And if possible, with a link in the first post that join both thread.
It is not annoying for me to have two threads for the girl cause when I do a search for a lady, I will find her no matter what section she has been reviewed in.
BUT, when I just browse into merb sections, I go in the INCALL section only to see the new posts (unread). very very rarely I visit the outcall section...
Since I do incall only, I like to skip the outcall only reviews and get only the posts for my interest.
So, the actual rules tend to mislead me in my browsing when a girl offers both in & out but is reviewed in only one section...
I will find the review if I'm doing searches but not always if i'm just browsing.
So I tend to agree that only one section should exist with one thread per lady.
However, this is interesting to know if the meeting happened incall or outcall. If the lady offers only incall or outcall or both...
I certainly do not want to read reviews of outcall only ladies. Lost of time
But I think at the beginning, we'll have tons of questions after a review: Was it incall or Outcall.
And I also think people may get used to it and start writing this information at the very beginning of their review posts.
So, in short, with the ACTUAL setup.
When I want to MEET a girl, I do seach with Merb search engine. I usually go into the advance search, and select TITLE ONLY and put the lady's name as the keyword. The section is not important in that case, I'll find her reviews no matter where it is...
When I just want to browse:
First I often use the "what's new" in the menu at the top. So here again, section is not really relevant, I'll click on what caught my interest.
Second, I might not go through all items in the "What's new" especially if there are many pages, then I go see directly the new posts in the section of my interest, INCALL section and LOUNGE.
So, really, I can live with the actual setup, but I may miss informations I'd like to know, ie, girls that are now offering incall but reviewed in the outcall only because of actual merb rules... But happily, it is more tolerated having two threads now.
I have no interest in incalls at all and there are a significant number of both indies and agencies that provide it exclusively. I have no interest in having to sift through incall reviews. This board is implemented as a forum, and as such review threads are already inundated with useless posts with no information like "yep I told ya - she's great!" and stuff along those lines. We already have to sift through that to get to actual reviews. Adding the hurdle of having to sift through incalls/outcalls in the same section is not something I am eager to see.
I think I am in the minority in this thread. As one who favours incall I wouldn't want to have to scroll through the outcall reviews to try and identify a new incall gem. There are SP's who do both incall and outcall and should be reviewed in both sections depending on how members encountered them but I am in favour of maintaining the status quo
L
Lily from Montreal
I think too it should be separate and I kind of disagree about the comment that it is the same if you see a lady incall or outcall, details about the location and whatever are of no interest to the outcall gents,if a lady offer both she should be reviewed in both not adding the incall review in the outcall if she was seen first outcall. I know it is more work but a separate thread should be made. There is already a lot of content as it is ,I think it would make the section way to massive...And that's coming from a lady who prefers to keep a low profile to keep the magic lol
I rather it stay separate. I am a Incall guy and having to tell which one is Outcall will be annoying. I had like 2 Outcall sessions in 8 years.
How hard is it to click once for Incall and click one more time in Outcall to check all reviews?
How hard is it to click once for Incall and click one more time in Outcall to check all reviews?
L
Lily from Montreal
Batista,the problem is that now it is blurry,if a lady has a incall review but also did outcall instead of creating a different thread it is all on the same. If it was kept separate ,as it is suppose to,there won't be any problems or confusion..
Lily is correct, I have a bunch of incall reviews in my outcall thread - a gentleman finally started an incall thread for me recently but I'd been doing them for a year. I like the idea of separate threads but it seems to confuse many people.
According to me:
If the rule of One review thread per girl only is maintained, there should be ONLY one review section. But many of us will find annoying to lose the incall/outcall information.
If the TWO Incall and Outcall sections are kept forever, this one review thread per girl rule should be changed to allow one review thread per section dependant of if you met the girl Incall or Outcall.
If the rule of One review thread per girl only is maintained, there should be ONLY one review section. But many of us will find annoying to lose the incall/outcall information.
If the TWO Incall and Outcall sections are kept forever, this one review thread per girl rule should be changed to allow one review thread per section dependant of if you met the girl Incall or Outcall.
I think we should merge both thread and create a post it, data list as the price list stating if the lady offers out, in or both.
Similar threads
