Doc Holliday said:
I can't believe the female judge giving Hopkins the fight....i mean, was she watching the same fight i was?
Outrageous scorecards are business as usual whenever Golden Boy is promoting fights. Judges Lombardi, McNair and Padillo scored the Santa Cruz/Casamayor respectively 114-113, 114-113, 113-114 in favour of Casamayor whereas practically every sport columnist, HBO people, the two nerds from Maxboxing and Harold Lederman all had it for Santa Cruz by a wide decision. Personally, I gave 11 rounds to Santa Cruz -vs- 1 to Casamayor.
Recently, two judges presented 115-113 and 117-111 scorecards in favour of Cristian Mijares whereas the third one had it 108-120 for Jose Navarro, a nonsense.
Back to Calzaghe/Hopkins, the punchstats were widely to the advantage of Calzaghe and Calzaghe also happened to be the boxer moving forward. On the other hand, Hopkins landed the cleanest, most solid, punches (landed the right-hand lead at will in the first four rounds) - some judges will always favour that aspect of a fight.