It’s that time of the year again..

Yup we should ...
I nominate for SP/ROY Sonia of Unicorn Healers
Best Agency : Unicorn Healers

I think, as last year, there should be separate threads for different nominations, and also some guidelines should be provided

Willgill said:

I think, as last year, there should be separate threads for different nominations, and also some guidelines should be provided

Click to expand...

Yes, we definitely need some rules on how to proceed with this, as there is an active "unofficial" thread already ...

https://www.merb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?161722-The-Unnofficial-quot-Best-of-2017-quot-thread/

True that other thread is a complicated unofficial best of where the category are a melting pot. I still found it very interesting and posted mine in it.

An official one with rules should be started. But not by me as I am quite bad with board rules and guidelines... And I usualy make many mistake as to how is eligible...

Out of the blue I nominate Halloween Mike to take care of it. HM?

Cheers,

The first thing we need is a volunteer to take on this job.

I like what Jalimon did with his categories in that unofficial thread.

https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...-quot-thread&p=1102124&viewfull=1#post1102124

Jalimon, why not start a new thread?

Call it "Official Best of 2017," or similar, then move your post there?

Each of us then uses Jalimon's categories as a basis to submit our own posts, adding and subtracting categories as seems appropriate for each of us? That way we can always go back to our own posts, edit them and add new categories, if so inspired ....

I cant remember if it was like that last year but... I think it would be nice to have separate polls for indy girls and agency girls, since some guys will only see agency girls and some will only see indy... I think it's more fair/logical if there are 2 separate polls. Anyone else thinks the same ?

Agree with Julia

Julia Sky said:

I cant remember if it was like that last year but... I think it would be nice to have separate polls for indy girls and agency girls, since some guys will only see agency girls and some will only see indy... I think it's more fair/logical if there are 2 separate polls. Anyone else thinks the same ?

Click to expand...

Was it ever like that?
It's creating tons of categories for a "contest" that already has so many categories. I feel like it looses a bit of its value and become a bit more... meaningless. Maybe I'm wrong. I'm new to all of this after all! Xxx

but what if some girls have been both in an agency and as an indy in 2017, do they double count?

ssj3 said:

Julia, I SO agree with you! I brought that point up last year because they lumped the indys and agency girls into one category which was not done the previous year. I suggested separating the two again but I was shot down.

Click to expand...

So that answers my question haha. Thanks! As I said I have no idea how all of this works at this point

Julia Sky said:

I cant remember if it was like that last year but... I think it would be nice to have separate polls for indy girls and agency girls, since some guys will only see agency girls and some will only see indy... I think it's more fair/logical if there are 2 separate polls. Anyone else thinks the same ?

Click to expand...

OK -

Agency SP of the year is Hanna from Unicorns

Indy SP of the year is Sexy Judy

Willgill said:

but what if some girls have been both in an agency and as an indy in 2017, do they double count?

Click to expand...

Well I guess you can vote for her in both polls (if you have seen her indy vote for her as best indy, if you met from the agency vote for her as best agency girl, and if you saw her in both situations just vote in both polls lol)

I imagined something like :

-Best SP 2017 (indy)
-Best SP 2017 (agency)

-Best Rookie 2017 (indy)
-Best Rookie 2017 (agency)

Etc... In separate threads

Ill leave this to you guys, I just thought it was more logical that way and thought I'd suggest it

Julia Sky said:

-Best Rookie 2017 (indy)
-Best Rookie 2017 (agency)

s

Click to expand...

Is an agency girl that goes Indy eligible for ROY as an Indy? Hmmm. Probably not I guess?

Julia Sky said:

Well I guess you can vote for her in both polls (if you have seen her indy vote for her as best indy, if you from at the agency vote for her as best agency girl, and if you saw her in both situations just vote in both polls lol)

Click to expand...

Very wise suggestion. I have to say Julia you are a really smart girl.

For best rookie, I am not sure if there are enough rookies to have two categories though

hungry101 said:

Is an agency girl that goes Indy eligible for ROY as an Indy? Hmmm. Probably not I guess?

Click to expand...

If you met her as an indy why not ?

Oh wait... You mean if she was not a Rookie in the first place ? Well then I dont know lol...

* brain cramps *

hungry101 said:

Is an agency girl that goes Indy eligible for ROY as an Indy? Hmmm. Probably not I guess?

Click to expand...

I don't think she is eligible as a rookie

What is considered a “rookie”? Someone who came out in 2017 only?