Gents,
I just think it is dangerous for bikes to be riding on Sherbrooke ...it is very tight for 2 cars that way and too many buses.
It also aggravates me when bikes swerve in and out of traffic and next thing I see is a damn bike on my driver side. Most do not respect traffic rules and as a pedestrian they have almost run me over.
On Ste. Catherine most bikers I see keep flying regardless of traffic, regardless of lights, regardless of pedestrians.
I know Sherbrooke on the north side between St. Laurent and Peel, and further, is a very risky place for bikes. There's very little room, if much of any. Many times bikers have pulled much too far in the right lane for cars to use it safely. When a car tries to turn right it's got to wait for that narrow window between finishing pedestrians and the red light. Bikers rarely respect turn signals and sometimes it becomes almost a deadly adventure when that window comes and bikers don't seem to want to look out for their own safety. On the south side of the street where all the hotels are it's worse. Double parking is frequent around there and now bikers are riding the lane divider markers between lanes while two lanes of cars are having a tough time dealing with one lane passage. I've seen some bikers take a Kamikaze attitude with buses too.
I don't know what bikers are thinking at times like that when they're risking being crippled or killed. Right of way doesn't save your life in a collision.
On Maisonneuve, almost every other street cuts into the bike path. When you're riding to get somewhere (i.e. you're riding fast) that path is super dangerous because there are consistently drivers that don't see you or think they'll outspeed you by the turn. I've had an accident that way.
If I had a bike I'd be worried about riding it downtown unless it's very early and traffic is light. Most Montreal drivers don't know the word courtesy to save their lives. The average driver tends to wait until about a second after the light turns green then charges full tilt regardless of anything until the light turns red or there's something they just can't get by. They don't give other cars a chance to do anything but go straight, so any driver trying to do anything else has to keep a watch out for what other cars are doing, never mind bikes.
Miasonneuve isn't bad in the morning before 10:00. I'm often driving along there just after 9:00 and the light traffic allows me to see everything and make relaxed choices. But at peak hours it gets to be like you're trying to dodge trouble all of the time. The biggest problem on many streets is there's no separate left turn lane like those on Rene Levesque where you can wait your turn safely. It's seize the opportunity when you can and that creates the risks.
The cars must make a stop but they can't see oncoming traffic unless they move up, directly into the bike lane.
I respect staying behind the bike paths while waiting for pedestrians as I try to turn, but when I see the people are about to clear I've got to move closer in anticipation. This is unavoidable. In the early days I remember waiting 3, 4 light changes because I was too far back even though I was first in line and the light would turn red with a few pedestrians still blocking my way. It gets ridiculous in some places.
A Metro pass costs $2.40. Parking, if you can find a spot, costs $3.00 per hour in downtown. Then you pay for gas. Please explain how it's cheaper to drive?
I avoid using my car whenever I can, especially at peak hours. The Metro is fine with me. If I'm lucky enough to have a good hotel location I'll walk. A couple of times I didn't touch the car between arriving and leaving, and before they changed some bus routes I was happy to use them. But even walking I still see too many bikers and drivers both taking a competitive me first attitude. It's not a good biking situation at many times in many places.
good luck,
Merlot