It is in fact a cruel entertainment and I cannot be objectively for it, being myself a non-violent relax guy. I do not wish to change the minds of people, I'm not that kind of guy either.
I have a sentimental attachement to that period of my life when I went to Corridas. It was my first time in a big outdoor "stadium", it was the sun, the smell of the "aguardiente" (sugar cane alcool if I remember), the hysterical crowd and many other things related to growing up in South America. I believe it can be understood, even if it will not diminish the cruelty itself, that emotions are not always reasonable, but still they are real and hard to avoid...Apply similar stories to the majority of people going there and you can understand
in part why it still exist today. It doesn't make it good...It just harder to understand in North America because we don't have any emotionnal or cultural attachement to it. It plays alot in understating the thing.
My next comments may even help those against it to be more ready to counter bugging guys like me, if the subject arise elsewhere!
A corrida have this "primal instinct flavor", a purely irrational, brutal but hard to resist emotion once there (as unbelievable it may sound). An exemple. I never watch boxing at home. That's one thing I don't like, I'm not interested into, etc. One day, someone offered me a good ticket to go watch a boxing night. I said why not, it's a new experience. To each his own experiences, and I'm really not an agressive type of guy, but to my surprise once the show started it's the irrational primal instinct that took up. I had a big adrenaline rush. It's disturbing to know that we ALL have that deep inside of us, and I know that even if I try to resist to it, when the button is pressed, i'm started (like in sex...same type of reaction). It's uncivilized, it's politically incorrect, it's strange, scary, sometimes cruel, but it's in us.
That brings the most important, even if more abstract, argument. I find the "civilized" argument not thruthfull to what we are in reality. It's "good thinking" people that are destructing/polluting the world, makings wars, using perception altering products while it's our basic instincts that make us procreate, survive and protect our loved ones. Some may find that I'm strecthing it, but if you look at the "uncivilized", take a group of indigenious people in Bresil, they are not the one cutting the trees to make fields for our beef to grow there to have a nice steak at the grocery. The Aztecas had rituals in wich extracting the heart of the ennemy in a big show was a way to prevent mass killings. Everything must be balanced and put in context. If we focus on the cruelty, yes it's cruel, but that's just, sadly, a side effect of what we are...We are the dangerous, the abusers and the manipulators in the animal kingdom and we need to give society ways to express our instincts. It's a proven way to control the masses and building civilizations. The "barbaric" Romans were enough "objective" to understand and admit it. I cannot imagine how hardocre they were, but it's the same thing. If one is able to take enough distance with the bull fighting itself, he can see that what make us civilized is things like Corridas. It's quite surprising and "illogic" at the first look, but I believe it's the truth.
Anyway, I pretend that our society is not that "civilized" in the way we like to believe it is, that our primal instincts are stronger than anything and that we need to find ways to let it out, be it by "simulating" our ancestral desire to hunt or by sleeping with other womans while engaged, etc. I understand that our society needs to find ways to control those basic urges to develop and survive.
I hope this wasn't too long. I tried something. I hope it helps people see other perspectives and that I won't leave the impression of being a brutal, senseless guy...wich I'm not. It's just a way to say that our brain can only fight for a while what is hiding deep inside.
Varia