Nominations for Best Reviewer 2014

[mauricevachon]

I guess it is that time of the year again.

The time to honor the Best Reviewer of 2014.

We are not looking for talkers. We are looking for doers. Those guys who go out in the trenches to do the research and reviewing work that make this board useful.

Previous winners:

2013 Delta 123
2012 ManApart
2011 ManApart

*****

On that score, the guys who post first reviews are particularly helpful. The guys who are willing to Take One For The Team (TOFTT). The Brendon Gallaghers of the hobbying world.

Off the top of my head, a few suggestions come to mind:

Delta 123 (my first choice, by far again this year)
Sexdor (a real worker)
BookerL (whom I'd rate for "most contributions," though not always reviews)
Uncle Bob (a tireless plugger)
Montreal_monk01
Cruiser777
NewYorkBill
Man911
Wimbledon
Sapman
Special K
SpecialAgent Moody
Garito

 

[johnybird]

I would always look out for Delta 123 reviews way before i joined this forum, I used to surf on MERC, my first choice as well as far as reviewers go. Even though out of your list one of SAM's & BookerL's reviews influenced me to book an SP.

 

[mauricevachon]

I agree. I suppose that is why this thread is dead.

It looks like Delta 123 is going to be the unanimous winner once again this year.

I can't find a single other poster who has started more than four review threads in calendar 2014.

 

[Doc Holliday]

I vote for Igna69. :thumb:

 

[lgna69xxx]

I nominate Doc Holliday, the Leo Komarov of the hobbying world :thumb: (who might this brendon gallagher fellow be) :noidea:

Would that be this guys brother?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbKayY6eD9k

I also nominate:


Delta123... the man is a legend, nuff said!

Cloudsurf..he could write a review every day of Julia and it would never get old

Pat98... easily "THEE" Ebony Reviewer of the Year, 2 years running :thumb:

Uncle Bob...always finding new gems to review so eloquently

Special K...really knows his ladies well and reviews them perfectly as a gentleman

Panthere...this guy writes with a passion I have rarely seen

Wallseye...has a way with words about the ladies and with them to

Reverdy...love all the sex position charts, really makes the reviews extra perfect!

HalloweenMike...I can never get enuf Kate reviews

Cruiser777...love the way you write so honestly

Almost any of these guys could represent MERB well as the Best reviewer of 2014, You Guys Rock!

 

[mauricevachon]

Results so far. Guys lets keep it down to three nominations per poster.

Delta 123, 3 votes
SpecialAgent Moody, 3 votes
Special K, 2 votes
Doc Holiday, 2 votes
CloudSurf
Igna, 1 vote
BookerL, 2 votes
Pat 98

 

[Atlante 007]

Je vote pour BookerL pour la qualité de ses reviews, son orthographe et la syntaxe sont excellents. UncleBob est aussi mon choix, car ses reviews sont précis et si vous allez voir la même SP, vous aurez exactement ce qu'il a écrit a propos de la SP. Je crois qu'il est le membre qui TOFT le plus!!!!!

 

[gologill]

Encore une fois cette c'est Delta123 qui devrait remporté la palme

 

[arthur_vandelay]

Delta123 by a country mile. He probably starts > 50% of the threads for the girls at the top 5 agencies?

Very discrete and no drama. But if you know how to read between the lines, you can tell a lot from his reviews.

Maybe he should get some kind of Lifetime Achievement Award, so other reviewers can be recognized?

 

[Halloween Mike]

Ces un no contest la... Delta par le nombre gagne facilement.

Sinon j'aprecie bien les review de Reverdy et BookerL que je met 2ieme et 3ieme pour la forme

 

[Octavian]

1.OhYesOui - too bad he's been banned,he gave the most accurate detailed reviews - 5 star reviewer

2.The Don - great all around reviews

 

[lougazebo]

#1 Delta 123
#2 igna69xxx
#3 Booker l

 

[Hal]

LOL, you guys do know that Delta was once banned for shill reviews for discounts from agencies/. To judge a reviewer, see what her writes and when you see a girl, see if you agree.

There is a lot of fake stuff here and overly exaggerated results due to vendor influences.

Agencies have even banned me for harsh reviews lol.

 

[Merlot]

Guys,

I don't have any trouble believing in Delta's accuracy, but the self-admitted taint on his record makes it difficult to nominate him.

1. Cloudsurf

2. Hungry101

3. Sharkman

There is a lot of fake stuff here and overly exaggerated results due to vendor influences.

Yeah, I think that's why this thread hasn't gotten a lot more responses. The integrity issue is a very large problem in some cases. Staying in good graces seems more important than having balls for the truth, but then being a guy and caving in for sex...well...surprise...NOT!!! But nominating guys so close to agencies? PEEEEUUUU!

Thanks for the mutual kissing club laughs from Toronto.

Cheers,

Merlot

 

[mauricevachon]

LOL, you guys do know that Delta was once banned for shill reviews for discounts from agencies/. To judge a reviewer, see what her writes and when you see a girl, see if you agree. There is a lot of fake stuff here and overly exaggerated results due to vendor influences. Agencies have even banned me for harsh reviews lol.

Your reminder about Delta 123 having been banned at one time is noted.

You are also correct that Delta (like most reviewers) refrains for publishing overtly negative reviews. As you noted, many agencies will ban reviewers who write negative stuff.

That said, Delta does generally manage to let readers know in small ways, whether a girl is a must...or whether she should be downplayed.

So on shear volume alone, I would rate him number 1.

****

I would however rate Hal higher....but we dont hear from him much these days.

 

[panthere]

I also nominate:

Panthere...this guy writes with a passion I have rarely seen

Thanks igna69xxx ..at least once compliment for my posting that are always honest and with passion i agree loll

 

[Octavian]

LOL, you guys do know that Delta was once banned for shill reviews for discounts from agencies/. To judge a reviewer, see what her writes and when you see a girl, see if you agree.

There is a lot of fake stuff here and overly exaggerated results due to vendor influences.

Agencies have even banned me for harsh reviews lol.

To find out who controls,you find who you cannot criticize.

 

[Delta123]

Coming from you, that's rich.

https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?31706-Hal-s-Goodbye&p=293029&viewfull=1#post293029

Thank you Reverdy you've been here way longer than me and it shows. Now I know who is this guy. loll so funny.

 

[lgna69xxx]

I know of a few guys who have "blogs" , twitter and/or facebook accounts pertaining to the industry. Most are a way to express their escapades in the business and are fun reads for them and others but some are about envy and jealousy of others in the biz, sort of like their own little "blue" all to themselves and the few who stumble upon them It amazes me how some take this little thing of ours called "the hobby" so seriously that it invloves the latter. Sad indeed, entertaining oui but also :crazy: /psycho


I wish i would have been around to visit the famous Doc Holliday Saloon, i heard those were the days.

 

[lgna69xxx]

Reverdy,

I think A LOT of ladies are still YMMV in this day and age and deservedly so. Can you imagine a guy calls to see a SP and he is stinking like boustan? Seriously tho there was a thread of a SP where a client got so upset that she would not DFK him that he made a big "stink" (yes, pun intended) about it until he got what he wanted. Un-freakin-real, no girl deserves that, paid or not! So your point that things have changed, I dont think as much as one might think in regards to ymmv, but maybe the majority of ladies stand there ground more now, hopefully.

Anyways we are getting off topic so to get back to the thread, how in the world could i leave out Hungry101 :noidea: sorry bro

Canbest! Those were indeed the days. :smile:

Apparently, some of them were really YMMV with it back then. Things have changed - lol.