Nominations for the Best Reviewer of 2012

[evillethings]

in alpha-order, for outcall only since that's all i'm interested in...

-cloudsurf for getting in there frequently, early and with a variety
-d123 (still a pain to have to troll another board to read, but...) same
-manapart for the same reasons as the boys above + i'll add he's the leading candidate to win for most times booking a girl on her 1st day / 1st shift

suffice it to say, anyone who posted a revu has been helpful and i hope ppl continue to contribute.

 

[SamKlemmons]

OK so lets see who we have do far:

ManApart (last year's winner) 10
MuffiinBuster 5
UncleBob 3
Cludsurf 3
SapMan 3
Rumples 3
Rex Kramer 3
Delta 123 (another board) 2
Hal 2
UNDFTD 2
Nylon Lover 2
Evil things 2
Smart Boy

Looks like a tight race for second place.

Will keep the thread open for another couple of days.

Any other suggestions?

 

[SamKlemmons]

I just read another great and topical thread started by ManApart and realized that we never finalized the Best Reviewer of 2012 winner.

Looking at the nominations, with all due respect to MuffinBuster, who is quite good, I am really not sure that we need to do an actual poll on this.

Unless I have a mass of objections I'd say we acclaim ManApart as the Reviewer of the Year for 2012, which would make it the second straight year.

Many thanks to all for their input.

 

[simonpaul]

Manapart is realy the best of best. He do a great job.

 

[man77777]

Problem is that he does 50% of the job in here. What would be merb without him ?

 

[Merlot]

Hello all,

There are a lot of good and great reviewers on this board. But the best is the one who provides the most complete picture to accurately tell members of what meeting any lady is really like, not just the fonder memories. That cannot be done if you are unwilling to be critical of the lady when there is something it's right to be critical about. Manapart does that the most consistently among the reviewers I've read.

Cheers,

Merlot

 

[ManApart]

Thanks guys.

It is a very difficult undertaking to try to get my reviews right, saying the good and the less than good, and yet carefully wording it so it doesn't offend anyone. As you may imagine, I am quite friendly with most agency owners and girls and it is really a tough line I try to walk. Trust me, it isn't that easy. After I write my reviews I reread and edit them for 20-30 mins before posting, to try to get it right. I take my reviews seriously, as I do most things I do in life, so it is nice to see people think they are good and appreciate it. My intention is really to help the guys who only are able to see a girl once in a while, to get the best results possible. I also enjoy helping unknown girls, who really deserve recognition, get a little attention for how great they are.

It looks like things will really be slowing down for me soon though. For my work, a transfer to Toronto is very likely in the near future. Maybe May or June. Time to get aquainted with my Terb compatriots!

 

[domvara]

it's sad to see you go MA thank you for all your reviews

 

[SamKlemmons]

For my work, a transfer to Toronto is very likely in the near future. Maybe May or June. Time to get aquainted with my Terb compatriots!

Well, we'd hate to see you go.

You are by far the best reviewer we have ever had out there (in my memory).

Many thanks MAP, on behalf of all those who follow your writing, the way wine reviewer Robert Parker's readers follow his selections...

*****

On another note, I would think twice about accepting a transfer to Toronto.

What difference does a few extra bucks make, if the quality of the girls you meet falls by half?

You'll spent almost all of your extra take-home pay on rent or house payments anyway.

And your SP budget will shoot through the roof.

I'd suspect that if you do the math, unless the opportunity is irresistible, you'd be better off here.

 

[man77777]

What difference does a few extra bucks make, if the quality of the girls you meet falls by half ?

And the quality of life... For a lot of reasons (beauty of the city, welcoming and openminded people, parties, girls, SP, price, low criminality........) Montreal is by far the best place to live in all this continent...

 

[MtlNewbie]

regarding the above above comment, either he knows your job situation personally, or he's making a lot of assumptions!

Anyways, I don't feel like I'm in any position to vote but I want to say that I appreciate the effort MA puts into his reviews, specifically, to put in a link so we can view the goods immediately after reading about the goods. Also reading his above post makes me appreciate the effort he puts in to be considerate to all parties involved considering the potential ramifications of his words on the livelihood of others; kind of reminds me of writing a reference letter. Thanks!

 

[EagerBeaver]

I will also miss MA's reviews as well. Having met MA at the recent GT, I will also say he will be a loss to the Montreal scene generally as he is a good guy. However, he will be able to have plenty of fun in Toronto. He is just going to pay more for it. The existence of Mirage Escorts should help ease the pain of his move. He is just going to have to get used to paying $300 per hour more often than not. I have met probably 3-4 girls in Montreal who "graduated" and went to Mirage.