It is not for the state to decide who will buy what and to limit choice and to create a unfair market. Let the ppl decide with their wallet. If they want to support Canadian dairy then they can do so and pay the higher prices. It is like Amazones, ppl say to support unions but will they really abandon convience to have delivery to their home? Competition drives innovation and gets the best product at the best price. Scap the dairy supply management and get rid of the CRTC.
Yeah, that take is oversimplified and ignores how the real world works - especially in Canada, where certain industries rely on stability over pure free-market chaos.
"Let the people decide with their wallet"
Sounds nice in theory, but in practice, free markets don’t lead to fair competition. The U.S. heavily subsidizes its dairy industry, meaning American milk would flood the Canadian market at artificially low prices, wiping out local farmers. Once that happens, guess what? Prices go up anyway because there's no local industry left to keep them in check.
"Competition drives innovation"
Sure, when markets are fair. But dairy isn’t a tech startup - it’s an essential part of the food system. Small farms can’t compete with mass-produced, hormone-tainted, subsidized U.S. milk. That’s not competition, that’s market destruction. Countries that ditched supply management (like your perfect example Australia) saw their small farms collapse, leading to corporate-controlled dairy and ongoing milk shortages.
"Scrap the CRTC"
The CRTC isn’t perfect, but it exists to prevent monopolies and keep Canadian media from getting steamrolled by U.S. corporations. Without it, we'd have Comcast-tier internet, fewer regional providers, and rural areas stuck using 2400 baud modems. The U.S. itself has strict media protection policies (FCC regulations, local content quotas), but I guess under Agent Orange Krasnov, that’s changing. Funny how the "free market" crowd never seems to mind corporate welfare. Why encourage a system that leads to : astronomical bailouts, tax breaks and loopholes, corrupted lobbying and regulatory favors... while promising everyone about some fantasy trickle-down effect that will never come?
"The Amazon Comparison is Dumb"
Amazon dominates because they kill competition, not because people “choose” them freely. They burn billions undercutting competitors, then jack up prices once they control the market. Do a quick search on how many entrepreneurs built businesses through Amazon, only to have Amazon clone their model and erase them from searches. The "free market" doesn’t mean much when giants rig the system harder than any government ever could. I much rather being able to fight the goverment over some conglomerate.
The Bottom Line
Dairy supply management isn’t perfect, but ditching it would gut Canadian farms and leave us dependent on tainted U.S. milk. The CRTC prevents a total American takeover of Canadian media - and if you haven’t noticed, real Canadians DON’T FUCKING WANT TO BE AMERICAN. "Let the market decide" is an idealistic and frankly ridiculous take that ignores real-world economics and corporate manipulation.
This isn’t some rat-infested depanneur you can run on vibes and wishful thinking. And the worst part? This is literally high school-level knowledge... in Canada.