Massage Adagio
Montreal Escorts

Members and the lacks of reviews recently

Status
Not open for further replies.

panthere

Active Member
Jul 16, 2004
2,539
12
38
ZION
Visit site
I don't agree with EB's criticism of how people review: for me, any review contains something useful.
Complaining that people's review are not to your taste will only lead to less reviews, which goes against the point of this board, doesn't it?
I second that...if you dont like my english...dont fuc**** read me!!!!... Si tu aime pas mon québécois parlé ..ne me lis pas calice non plus ...POINT!!! If you are not down with it...take the highway!!!

P.S. 14h10....if you dont like my post=put me on your ignore list...it is soooo simple...and no conflict will be created!!!
si tu aime pas mes post...met moi dans la liste noire...ces simple pourtant...et ca évite les conflits..
 

EagerBeaver

Veteran of Misadventures
Jul 11, 2003
20,370
3,268
113
U.S.A.
Visit site
I never said any such thing. I said a lot of guys cannot write reviews and then when they are criticized by others they don't handle it well. I never said anything about whether such reviews, even if deficient in some ways, are not board worthy. Please don't put words in my mouth.

Panthere all you do is stir shit! Your comments have nothing to do with this discussion. I was commenting very generally on the reviews of others, nobody in particular. I never even read your reviews dude! Guess what you are not the center of the MERB universe.
 

rollingstone

Member
Sep 4, 2006
653
9
18
I have to agree with EB. When I go reading reviews I am generally looking for her general look and attitude, and whether the person would repeat. I am pretty democratic in the range of looks and physique of the SPs I see, I care far more on the effort she puts into presenting herself, and her attitude (which is a difficult thing to gauge). Most of the time the person I am seeing is so well reviewed I have nothing to add. Other times, frankly speaking, the SP was an HDH and I don't want to be drawn into the whole 'was it worth it for that much cash?" debate. Anyways, I will be spending a week in MTL before the end of the year and I intend to write more reviews this time.
 

UncleBob

Well-Known Member
Nov 9, 2010
2,132
152
63
Earth
I used to do more reviews because I was like in a quest of finding DA perfect SP.
While I think she does not exist or very hard to find, I found few that are pretty closed to perfect.
A perfect SP is one that is full GFE and more, young, pretty spinner, natural, and that will make me repeat with her without being fed up after a while.

So, since a year, maybe two, I review a lot less because those "near perfect" SPs I repeat with are already very well reviewed.

I do not see much of Agency girls cause I feel rushed and by experience, I used to get a better GFE with SP I contact directly.
I used to find these SP on Ann123, Annonce Intime but these days, I find there are not much ladies that stand out from the crowd on the ad's site. A lot of B&S also on these ads site...
So I stick to regulars for now.

So don't worry, I still read reviews, and I still like to make reviews. But at the moment, I'm happy with regulars.

I am very agree with OOBE, all reviews, no matter the type of review and info given is welcome and might be usefull.
All reviewers have a style. You can like it or not, it is still a review. We are not all novel writers. This board does not impose a way to write reviews.
I personnaly do not like some reviews. Especially rude ones, with no respect. I do not like long ones... But others like it. What counts to me is contribution.
The more we have reviews on a SP the more we can find the right info for us.
 

hungry101

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2007
5,838
546
113
I second that...if you dont like my english...dont fuc**** read me!!!!... Si tu aime pas mon québécois parlé ..ne me lis pas calice non plus ...POINT!!! If you are not down with it...take the highway!!!

I agree with OOBE & Panthere. And Panthere, You get your point across quite well. I wish I could speak and write in French as well as you do in English. In fact I am trying to learn another language and it is muito dificil!

Even if a Hobbyist says I saw her and it was a good experience and all that is written is accurate. I wish people would say more about their date. Services offered, services provided, extras, cost. A description of looks how they dressed and prepared themselves for the date. It is helpful to know what and if they like to drink and how personable they are, are they clock watchers etc...I scan reviews for all of these things. If you are thrilled then I am more likely to put this girl on my TDL.

TER has some fairly rigged rules about using numbers for for services and for looks. EB has pointed out in the past that these are useful with TER because you can click on the members review history and you can see if he is an easy grader or not (I argue that a guy that sees Backpage girls for 15 minutes should have lower numbers). The point is that numbers are a quick way to communicate your experience and for you to force rank SPs.

I read a review once that said only the following (and I am paraphrasing):

See this girl! Don't miss this one. I don't like to give details but believe me this one is a can't miss.

And that was it. The above is the only type of review I object to. Can you imagine if you read a movie, book or restaurant review like this?

Now, if you do not like my reviews please put me on your ignore list.
 

EagerBeaver

Veteran of Misadventures
Jul 11, 2003
20,370
3,268
113
U.S.A.
Visit site
The one thing I like about the TER review system is that with one click you see all the reviews the member ever posted. I have reviews on TER that were posted in 2002 that are still there.

More importantly if a guy gives a girl a 6 in looks you might check his history and find it is the highest looks score he ever posted. I saw one guy who also gives everyone a 10. However most guys are across the board and you can see if they gave a girl an 8 and you agree with the review then the 9 they gave the new girl will mean something to you.

Like for example if I give a girl a 8 on looks and someone who saw the same girl agrees with my 8, then my 9 will mean something to them. I try to pick out the girls reviews of girls I have seen and see which posters assess as I would and then look at their other reviews.
 

panthere

Active Member
Jul 16, 2004
2,539
12
38
ZION
Visit site
I agree with OOBE & Panthere. And Panthere, You get your point across quite well. I wish I could speak and write in French as well as you do in English.

First thanks...and yes i always try to get my point across ;)
i dont gonna get into details...but some here..and they recognize each other..doesnt like my english!!! sorry i am not perfect...but i always try to do my best...and i think for someone who judge that...(i dont gonna say the words that is coming to me right now lolll)...Like if a guy at some event or in the street ask me in english i gonna try my best to help him...even if a guy in english is trying to speak to me close enough in french..i dont gonna judge him...and i am gonna BE GLAD that he is trying...anyway...i gonna skip the subject..but thanks again mister hungry101 :peace:
In fact I am trying to learn another language and it is muito dificil!
Btw is it spanish you are trying...cause that language...i loveeee it soo much...i know a couple of sentence...but that is it...but amazinggg ....and would love to know that one..but nobody i know speak spanish in my friends...realllyyy too bad..

Even if a Hobbyist says I saw her and it was a good experience and all that is written is accurate. I wish people would say more about their date. Services offered, services provided, extras, cost. A description of looks how they dressed and prepared themselves for the date. It is helpful to know what and if they like to drink and how personable they are, are they clock watchers etc...I scan reviews for all of these things. If you are thrilled then I am more likely to put this girl on my TDL.
I do totally agreeee with you on that note ..perfecto senior ;)
 

panthere

Active Member
Jul 16, 2004
2,539
12
38
ZION
Visit site
Guess what you are not the center of the MERB universe.

LMAO...lolllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll... BUT I AM MY CENTER OF MY UNIVERSE :peace: and trust me you are not!! ....


Panthere all you do is stir shit!

If i do stir shit...you should recognize it...cause it is always about you and you and you ..and curiously YOU dont get ban for it...anyway...stay on the topic!!!

I never even read your reviews dude!

BTW I GUESS YOU DO READ ME!!!...why dont you put me on your ignore list...:amen:
 

EagerBeaver

Veteran of Misadventures
Jul 11, 2003
20,370
3,268
113
U.S.A.
Visit site
Panthere I said I do not read your reviews and I don't. This is a discussion about reviews, not your posts, and it is not about bans or who should be banned. All you are doing is stirring shit and not adding anything to this thread.
 

MaxxxEdge

Active Member
Jun 17, 2010
506
37
28
Fuck more… argue less… 'nuff said.
 

panthere

Active Member
Jul 16, 2004
2,539
12
38
ZION
Visit site
Fuck more… argue less… 'nuff said.

I agreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee sooo muchhhh

Panthere ...All you are doing is stirring shit and not adding anything to this thread.

But i guess you should put me on ignore list...but instead you want to attack ME...anyway...damn you are hard to understand...PUT ME ON YOUR IGNORE LIST...cause YOU are stirring the shit...like you always do...and nobodyyyyy here is gonna accuse me of something i didnt do...

Why dont you put me on your ignore list...:amen:
 

BookerL

Gorgeous ladies Fanatic
Apr 29, 2014
5,789
7
0
Northern emisphere
Hi all
I am back from business in Vancouver ,I have reviewed 3 ladies but one of them twice because of two pleasant encounters .
C-36 does not really bother me because sex is not illigal between consenting adult and merb doesn't sell its forum to share are good and bad experiences and speak of different topic .


Cheers


Booker
 

hungry101

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2007
5,838
546
113
The one thing I like about the TER review system is that with one click you see all the reviews the member ever posted. I have reviews on TER that were posted in 2002 that are still there.

More importantly if a guy gives a girl a 6 in looks you might check his history and find it is the highest looks score he ever posted. I saw one guy who also gives everyone a 10. However most guys are across the board and you can see if they gave a girl an 8 and you agree with the review then the 9 they gave the new girl will mean something to you.

Like for example if I give a girl a 8 on looks and someone who saw the same girl agrees with my 8, then my 9 will mean something to them. I try to pick out the girls reviews of girls I have seen and see which posters assess as I would and then look at their other reviews.

Yes, this is a way to calibrate the numbers. I agree. I wish I could click on a MERB member and click Reviews only and 1.) look for the range of ratings the Merbite gives to girls and to 2.) look for girls in common that the two of us have seen.

I wil say that I take recommendations from fellow hobbyists and I also look for reviews like guys like K who seems to have similar tastes.

Remember that discussion that you and I had about the TER member that I am still convinced wrote a false review on a girl only to receive 15 days of VIP membership. I am still convinced of this. You looked at the same data and said I tended to give higher range of ratings while the hobbyist in question tended to give a lower range of ratings. This is true but I countered that I only see prior reviewed girls that are either reputable indies or from reputable agencies and I pay 200-450$ per hour while the New York hobbyist in question was seeing all New York Back Page girls - some for 15 minutes!!!! Now there is a reason that my average rating value is higher. I wouldn't even see suck scum.
 

Merlot

Banned
Nov 13, 2008
4,111
0
0
Visiting Planet Earth
Hello People,

...its been silence from some of the old time members like Iggy...

Mike, you'd need an industrial strength vice grip to squeeze every one of his nearly 9,000 posts to get one review out of him, unless you count those cozy one-liner posts or his admiration for Joe.t. They and others have gone almost completely back channel with their escort information, and that's a cheat for the board that has gotten to be a bigger and bigger habit.

Regarding criticism:

Some of those so-called criticisms are attack replies where the responder poses like he was actually there to see what went on and contradicts what the reviewer says happened. Some of these are just pure shill attacks, and they are easy to spot because the attacker acts like he was the one reviewing from a completely different experience.

One of the most terrible cases of attack replies to reviews involves a great guy like Cloudsurf. It's bad enough members attack reviews that are critical of their favorite ladies or agencies, but going after Cloudsurf because he's allegedly always positive? What the hell is that about? Are these attackers just so miserable that they have to attack someone who knows how to enjoy his experiences. It's ridiculous.

A lot of members act like their own experience must be true for everyone, so they attack anything different. I never understood why anyone had to insist what they did with a lady had to be true about her for all or presume something nasty was true about the reviewer. We admit that chemistry is a very real and powerful factor, then some of the same people act like there's no such thing.

There's another odd bad habit. A close associate of mine, one of the most respect reviewers ever who posted his famous A-List, would get inquiring PMs, which is fine. But not satisfied with the answers some who try to get very personal information that became badgering and maybe very close to stalking. Of course it's alright to ask about details of an encounter with a lady, but keep your space. Getting some helpful detail is not an invitation to try to become part of anyone's personal life, especially not pushing for that.

...the best way to do a review is post all physical descriptions like hair color, breasts, body type, tattoos and piercings and language skills in French and English,...

This seems very reasonable, but where's the difference between this information and what every short bio list on an agency website tells us. Too many details an unnecessary, but why not something like: The lady arrived dressed in a silk dress with stocking and high heels...she showed me she enjoyed kissing sensually...she was comfortable being in several positions for sex. I don't think that's going to far or guaranteeing anything for objectionable clients. It's a lot better than putting the lady on the spot for CIM, SW, greek and more.

Do the police would really try to link our profiles to us...

It would seem to be a very doubtful effort for the police to gain good evidence or proof, especially on out of towners. However, the more one is closely associated with an agency and has left his "finger prints" there would be what not to have laying around. It shouldn't affect reviews much, except that many might worry more than they should. People have a habit of overreacting, but in this case where the stakes are higher in their personal lives as well as any possible legal consequences being scared is natural.

I don't agree with EB's criticism of how people review: for me, any review contains something useful.
Complaining that people's review are not to your taste will only lead to less reviews, which goes against the point of this board, doesn't it?

People complain about style and the type of content like rating systems then give others a hard time about that instead of appreciating the effort. I don't ses any room for criticism on these grounds. They should be grateful when people take the time to write publicly. If you need clarity about certain details that concern you then send a PM. Most like me are happy to give a little more information or clear up a misunderstanding.

...I don't want to be drawn into the whole 'was it worth it for that much cash?" debate.

Well, there are times when this is annoying and other times when it can be a service. Questioning value can put the lady and agency on notice that while they are doing well there is a limit on the rates in this market. This is one of the things I find disturbing about all the disingenuous attacks on critical reviews. It's stifling a critical element that helps control inflation and keep value at rational levels.

The one thing I like about the TER review system is that with one click you see all the reviews the member ever posted.

One of the best assets any escort review board can have that is missing here is a function that would allow members to quickly see a review history for a member. I've seen and used TER in this way for Boston in the past and it was very helpful.

The other big problem here is that when I enter a name to search I get a ridiculous hodgepodge of totally unrelated topics, some without even the faintest resemblance to anything about an escort or an agency. It's really stupefying how that issue has not been addressed. Even precise keywords in titles I know 100% are there don't come up at times.

I second that...if you dont like my english...dont fuc**** read me!!!!... Si tu aime pas mon québécois parlé ..ne me lis pas calice non plus ...POINT!!! If you are not down with it...take the highway!!!

Français est la plus belle langue du monde. Italienne est deuxième. J'aimerais parler parfaitement le français, mais je sais seulement un peu.

Ne vous inquiétez pas EB. Il "pense" qu'il est le centre de l'univers de chacun. :lol: Tout le meilleur pour vous.

Bonne journee',

Merlot
 

pat98

ebonylover retired...
Mar 26, 2010
1,314
120
63
Montreal
Mike, you'd need an industrial strength vice grip to squeeze every one of his nearly 9,000 posts to get one review out of him,
I just browsed your last 5 pages of post history! ( was enough )
Guess what?
No reviews ... :D
So please give us a break with that ...

Bonne journée et bon weekend
:peace:
 

EagerBeaver

Veteran of Misadventures
Jul 11, 2003
20,370
3,268
113
U.S.A.
Visit site
Merlot i guess you missed the Mod30's warning about keeping posts topic related with the very first and very last portion of your post commenting on Panthere's post? It seems if there is any shit stirring op to be seized, you do it even in the face of a moderator warning.
 

Merlot

Banned
Nov 13, 2008
4,111
0
0
Visiting Planet Earth
People,

I just browsed your last 5 pages of post history! ( was enough )
Guess what?

You mean you're using a silly cop-out to protect your bud, which you did badly. As you know my last recent review is on page 6. Nice lie Pat.

I saw three ladies in July. Each was reviewed thoroughly, not in the "cheapass" and useless..."dude, she's hot, I give her a 9"...manner.

Holly Independent - Post 6:
https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...DY-DUO-(Ex-Raven-amp-Lizbeth)&highlight=holly

Darla of Wildtime - Post 39:
https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?89987-Darla-Wiltime-ex-MTLGFE/page3&highlight=darla

Megan of G4U - Post 80
https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...rls-Ex-Veronica-XXXtase/page6&highlight=megan

Very short reviews that get to the point are perfectly fine with me. I have nothing against a different and very economical style as long as there's substance. But as Pat98 knows, regurgitation of a few words anyone can copy is NOT a review, and some people are infamous for that.

I wish people would say more about their date. Services offered, services provided, extras, cost. A description of looks how they dressed and prepared themselves for the date. It is helpful to know what and if they like to drink and how personable they are, are they clock watchers etc...I scan reviews for all of these things. If you are thrilled then I am more likely to put this girl on my TDL.

It would be very interesting to take the options advertised by the agency for the lady and compare which of these were provided that the client asked for. It might be boring like a list of checkoffs, but it would offer something solid to compare as a matter of consistency. The rest would give it what I call that necessary flavor of the encounter. These would make good standards for reviews, which some would not pass.

Merlot i guess you missed the Mod30's warning about keeping posts topic related with the very first and very last portion of your post commenting on Panthere's post? It seems if there is any shit stirring op to be seized, you do it even in the face of a moderator warning.

HEY...mr.integrity. :rolleyes: and what about this...^^^

bonne fin de semaine a tous,

Merlot
 

luv2luv

Member
Sep 18, 2011
49
0
6
For years I was a lurker on merb. I was meeting hot girls and having the best sexual experiences of my life thanks to the reviews I would read. However I wasn't contributing any reviews myself.

As HM states initially to start this thread, a couple of years ago I noticed that merb members were not sharing their experiences. I figured it was because info on girls was being exchanged by PM.

I decided last year to start posting some reviews. I don't post a lot of reviews because I will only post about girls that I recommend. I won't write any negative review.

I think that there are a variety of reasons why merb members don't share all of their experiences. The most obvious is that a girl with good reviews is harder to book.
 

UncleBob

Well-Known Member
Nov 9, 2010
2,132
152
63
Earth
I just browsed your last 5 pages of post history! ( was enough )

As you know my last recent review is on page 6. Nice lie Pat.

Nice try Pat. I guess it was too boring to read more up to page 6 lol.

Anyway, it is not the first time Merlot attacks Iggy on his ratio "Reviews vs Post Count". Pathetic and always cheap shot...
If this is not shit stirring, what is it?

Iggy is contributing in his manner. He organizes great parties and he is an nice and honnest man.
Iggy loves sports.
Iggy likes Joe T very much indeed. They are good friends.

What is wrong with that?
Is it his popularity that bothers you and then makes you use your usual sarcasm to legally attack him?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts