Iggy has made some great points. Evillethings has made some good ones also, but i don't totally agree with what he wrote. JC....well, he's being JC as usual.
In Tampa Bay, their success had as much to do with the change of ownership than they did with Yzerman replacing Lawton. Ownership was mess in Tampa until the team was finally sold. Two owners who hated one another & one of them constantly mingling in the team's day-to-day operations. No wonder Barry Melrose got out. Jay Feester was a good hockey man who was let go by the former owners. Lawton wasn't ready for the GM job. He didn't have much experience in managing a hockey team. Stevie Y learned next to great hockey men in Detroit ever since he retired.
To be honest, the only mistake i can pin on Burke is the fact he didn't tank the season two years ago. The Leafs could easily have picked third or fourth had they not picked up Martin Gerber & make him play in every game until the end of the season. If they would have stuck with what they had in the system, mostly Cujo, they'd have Brayden Schenn on their team today. They might even have been able to move up with a deal & draft Victor Hedman. But no.....they went on a winning streak with Gerber between the pipes & next thing you know, they wind up drafting 7th & wind up with Nazem Kadri.
I can't say the Kessel trade was a mistake. Tyler Seguin might be a total bust (anyone remember Patrick Stefan? David Legwand?), who knows. Same thing with the pick the Bruins will get from the Leafs at this coming draft. Phil Kessell just turned 22 & he already has 4 years under his belt. He's steadily improving & might score 50 goals one day. Burke gambled & that's what he's paid to do. Would you rather have someone like Pierre Gauthier as your GM?
You want to see a gamble that's not paying off? Lou Lamoriello & the NJ Devlis signing Ilya Kovalchuk, meanwhile throwing away the future by having lost prospects & draft picks to get him. It probably will cost them Zach Parise since they're wasting all of their budget on Ilya Kovalchuk!
The Leafs are the youngest team in the NHL & most experts expect good things for them in the future. They're in much better shape than the likes of Ottawa, New Jersey & Calgary. The Leafs have rebuilt their goaltending& it's probably the organization's biggest strenght. Defence? A disappointment, but everyone was saying Burke had made some great moves when he signed Komisarek & Beauchemin. Getting Phaneuf, Sjostrom & Aulie from the Flames wasn't a trade, it was a heist on the part of the Leafs GM. He finally got rid of the supposedly untradeable Jason Blake & the awful Vesa Toskala. In return, he got a veteran who won the Conn Smythe (and the Stanley Cup) in J-S Gigure, whose contract expires this season. You can't ask for a more classy guy! The free agents he picked up are prospects on the big league team and/or the Marlies. The farm team was in bad shape & Burke has filled it with young prospects who will one day develop into useful NHL players.
The team is on the right track, but it seems everyone is being way too impatient (this is Toronto, after all). This is year 2 of the 5-year plan to make the Leafs contenders again. Burke will have tons of $$ at the end of the season to sign free agents. Giguere & Kaberle's contracts will be off the books & who knows how much more he'll have if he can find a way to trade away one or two of his most expensive defencemen. Once again, any knowledgeable hockey fan with a brain has to admit that this team's future looks very bright.