I don't know how you cannot cheer for a guy like that.
Nobody said they were not cheering him. I noted the prior baseball examples of Raul Ibanez and Matt Carpenter, who at similar ages and coming off injury plagued poor seasons, each experienced a career renaissance with the NY Yankees. While that's a possibility for Max, I think odds are well stacked against it with a double Achilles. The Patrick Marleau year 2/3 comparison with the Leafs is more likely what they will get.
But we have only discussed production and not leadership. Hopefully what he can really bring the lockerroom is a veteran leader that some of those prima Donnas on the Leafs will listen to. Last year they were an embarrassment and I think management saw that the team is lacking in veteran leadership after the debacle display against the Bruins. Leafs management does not want to see that happen again and want to upgrade the professionalism in their locker room. So they think he can help with that.
The Leafs managed to get their young coach fired and caused lots of people to lose money betting on them against the Bruins, a team that was very banged up and ready to be beaten. That series exposed a lot of painful leadership issues for the Leafs, which were on full display to a national TV audience.