At what height/weight would a sp/girl be considered FAT?

[azzaro]

I kinda like the few extra pounds..like 20-30 pounds according to height/weight but after that would be fat..example 5'7" and 140-150 is ok with me..but 170 would be a bit too much (for 5'7).Add /Subtrace 10 pounds for each increase/decrease in height in this FAT formula. Is there guys out there who don't mind the 20-30 extra pounds like this ..?

 

[master_bates]

I'm not shy to admit I like my women curvy so a few extra lbs is ok in my book

 

[chef]

I like them curvy too. To me the words "slim" and "sexy" are mutually exclusive.

 

[Turbodick]

You can't really quantify it, since a well-toned lady would weigh more than someone who has more body fat and is the same fat.
I consider noticeable flab/cellulite as fat.

 

[montreal_monk01]

I love them voluptuous as well.
In my books (I am not following the conventional measurements of being skinny/slim/fat), I follow the following measurements:
-sexily curvaceous:
5'1 to 5'5 between 115-125lbs
5'6 125-127 lbs
5'7 127-135 lbs
5'8 to 5'11 135-140 lbs
-fat:
5'5 to 5'5 with more than 125lbs (Mind you, I recently had an affair with a sexily curvaceous lady of 5'4 130lbs)
5'6 with more than 127 lbs
5'7 with more than 135 lbs
5'8 to 5'11 with more than 145lbs
Of course, from one lady to the other, this theory of numbers may not necessarily match the real body shape, but in general those numberings fit in my appreciation of "sexily curvaceous" Vs "fat".
As for the top body-types that turn me on (the ones I consider as ultimate perfect body shape for a woman):
5'5 126lbs + 5'6 to 5'7 140lbs (again, most of the girls I found ultimately sexy were in that height/weight ratio ...but
that does not necessarily mean that all ladies with same height/weight have the looks that turn me on).

 

[C Dick]

The way to compare is with Body Mass Index, or BMI. 19 to 24 is considered ideall. For women, here are some values:

Height Weight BMI
5-0 100 19.5 This is what I would consider perfect
5-0 120 23.4
5-4 120 20.6
5-4 140 24.0
5-8 140 21.3
5-8 160 24.3
So for me, a women with a BMI of 20 is about right. You can do the calculations at http://www.nhlbisupport.com/bmi/

 

[Melody]

Can I ?!?

Good grief ... settling for second best isn't my thing, especially since the plump ones charge the same or close.
5'4 and 115 (max) and 5'10" 140-ish.
Anything more and I feel, I know, the woman isn't watching what she eats ... scoffs down too fast .. lol

Interesting !!
**Note to myself: Dont forget if you gain weight to low down your prices.

Have you ever heard of someting called "metabolism" ?

Hi guys !

And to all you who like "curvy and voluptuous" girl... maybe you would like me ! Althought, reading your posts, I would be obese!!! lollll Which I'm absolutly not ! But I do have curves and littles cushions!

I think you may have been looking on escorts websites for too long (where they most of the time remove 10,20 or 25 pound to the girl on the pic!)

I'm 5'6" and trust me, if I was 125 lbs I would scare the childrens looking like a squeletton! You seem to forget the "frame" factor...

It's also a fashion thing guys! I'm now considered as having extra pounds... but go back in the 50's and I would be perfect... also back to the renaissance, I look like Boticcelli's Venus. ( I must say this is kind of frustrating for a girl sometimes )

I personnaly appreciates being in contact with differents bodies types... Probably because I am a "second best"

 

[Sylvia Vixen]

Had to jump in on this one.

First off, I think that the vocabulary used to discribe a girls weight has to be considered here. Many men out there like their women curvy, voluptuous, with a little extra meat... Versus the word fat which has a derogatory conotation.

But it all comes down to personal taste. I have had clients who thought I was the perfect weight. They used words such as voluptuous. They described me as a woman with curves at all the right places. I have also had clients who described me as fat or chubby. I personaly laugh at someone who calls me fat because IMHO I am very far from fat. But I can understand that if a man's preference in women is a skinny girl with no hips...well I might pretty damn fat in his book.

I guess what I am trying to say is that when someone writes that a girl has "a few extra pounds"... she has a few extra pounds from what? a squeleton type body? a normal healthy weight?

I still don't understand why we put down a weight in pounds. Using your clothing size, or measurments in inches would be so much more telling of what a girl's size really is. The number means nothing. I wear a size 8 in pants. I do alot of sports and my muscle mass varies. I have gone from 130 to almost 145 at times... but always wore that size 8. My size didnt change, just the components of my body. Isnt that a perfect example that the nmber of pounds a girls weighs is not really a good indicator?

 

[MG_mtl]

Same question should apply to us men...

I'm sure a large % of you perverts would be in the "FAT" category as well...

 

[J. Peterman]

Too many variables..................

.........I have to evaluate the situation on a case by case basis. I can not define fat, but I know fat when I see it.

 

[Techman]

If a girl is too big to fit into my jeans, I have no interest in getting into hers.

Now this is what I consider to be obese...

http://www.myspace.com/sexycurvygal


And yes, I stole the link from master_bates thread here: https://merb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=28466

Techman

 

[metoo4]

As others are saying, what's fat? What standard is being used? So many times I've read reviews stating "Great body", "perfect tits", "amazing ass" and, the ladies in question just didn't do it for me, no attraction whatsoever!

It's all in each other's opinion. My toothpick girl could be somebody else's perfect body, same as my "fat ass chick" could be somebody's dream cushion. To each it's own!

Now... If agencies could start put REAL measurements on their sites... Most ladies probably don't have a clue of their weight so, asking them isn't likely to get accurate info, nor than just "guestimating" a weight! How many ladies are 5'5" and 115 pounds?? How many are "B cups"?? According to agencies, lots and lots!

I even had a lady who "gained" 2 inches, from 5'3 to 5'5 from booking time to the time she made it to the room! And she also gained 20 pounds during those few hours and went from Bs to As... And this wasn't a bait-switch type of agency. They just asked the girl her measurements and never actually confirmed!

Breast-talking, it's known by anybody who work in ladies clothing that most women don't know their bra size and pick whatever seems to fit and look good. I was told this by a lady friend who worked for a lingerie manufacturer. She said that was the most common "mistake" when she was doing product showing for ladies. MOst ladies were amazed how comfortable they could be with the proper bra size, when adjusted properly!

 

[Techman]

Everyone's idea of beauty is personal and I will never denigrate anyone's desires. But fat is fat no matter whether someone loves large women or not. Some people love anorexic waifs and they are no more attractive to me than drastically overweight women. I like a woman to feel like a woman when I hold her, soft in some places and firm in others. A washboard stomach and very low body fat don't do it for me, but neither do thighs that rub together when she walks. My body is far from perfect and I would never expect or demand perfection in someone else. But there are limits I will not go beyond.

 

[Mike Mercury]

At 5-8 a girl above 130 starts to be a bit big in places. Size 6 & 8 is okay.
At 5 to 5-2. Going over a 105 will start to be a bit heavy however the girl can qualify as petite if she does not turn pudgy. When she is pudgy she has to be below 20 years old.

 

[Melody]

Breast-talking, it's known by anybody who work in ladies clothing that most women don't know their bra size and pick whatever seems to fit and look good. I was told this by a lady friend who worked for a lingerie manufacturer. She said that was the most common "mistake" when she was doing product showing for ladies. MOst ladies were amazed how comfortable they could be with the proper bra size, when adjusted properly!

Breast talking too... I may be wrong but as you talk about it I was thinking that maybe for girls with smaller breast A, B, bra size can be something unimportant... but when you have a bigger breast then I think in that case having a good bra become something important and girls know their sizes. Well, as good as they actually can because this vary a lot.

I always buy quality bra (and this is expensive ) but from a brand to an other the sizes changes. I can wear from 36C to 38D which is a big difference. It can be 36C, 38C, 36D or 38D it change on the model and on the brand... So even when you know your bra size... well it's not that obvious!

By the way metoo, I totally agree with you on the "If agencies could only pu real mesurement on their sites" Often I see pictures of girl taller and bigger than me and I see 5'8", 130 lbs !!! YEAH RIGHT !!
Now, when you build your own site you have too ask yourself: "Ok, do I put real weight or do I put "escort weight"? " Because if you put your real weight OMG people will thing you are obese !!
I have personnaly always think that being honnest is the best way... and this have actually always served me well...
I think sometimes agencies should stop trying to fool people... anyway, it's not even usefull now that everybody knows...

 

[Melody]

At 5-8 a girl above 130 starts to be a bit big in places.

OMG !!!!!!!!
I hope this is "escort weight" speaking lollll

 

[Turbodick]

I still don't understand why we put down a weight in pounds. QUOTE]

I'm surprised the Canadian Metric Nazi's don't make the weight/height in Kilograms and Metres, then no one would know what the numbers mean anyway.

 

[wolfman]

some numbers mentioned.........

are scary.........5'5" 130 lbs considered fat is ridiculous......
there are 3 types of frames women come in.....small medium and large....in other words small boned, etc.......a small framed woman at 5'5" could weigh any where between 117 and 130 lbs.......and large framed woman at 5'5" could weigh between 137 and 155 lbs this not making her fat........there is a bigger bone mass which makes her seem bigger(fatter) but she isnt... this being said I myself prefer a woman with some meat on her bones over the anorexic look.......

just my 2 scents

take a look at this webpage it'll help with seeing what's what

http://www.fuelthemind.com/health/nutrition/your_ideal_weight.html#woman_chart

so Melody at 5'6" 155 lbs you are not fat at the most u got curves in the right places.....je vais le voir bientot...........and Slyvia there is no way in hell anyone should call you fat.......have a nice day

 

[Ducon]

I'm surprised the Canadian Metric Nazi's don't make the weight/height in Kilograms and Metres, then no one would know what the numbers mean anyway.

Are you sure you remember what the word "Nazi" means?
Also, metric units mean something to quite a few millions of people out there ( see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_system ) , especially since there are lots of foreigners here in Montreal.
Imperial units mean jack shit to me, for example, apart from the pint.

Since the sex industry has its own non-official units anyway,
in the end it's the photos that matter.
Unfortunately, photographers are apparently not good at showing women's curvaceous hips...
as if wide womanly hips were a turn-off that they try to hide...

 

[Firewire]

I still don't understand why we put down a weight in pounds. Using your clothing size, or measurments in inches would be so much more telling of what a girl's size really is. The number means nothing. I wear a size 8 in pants. I do alot of sports and my muscle mass varies. I have gone from 130 to almost 145 at times... but always wore that size 8. My size didnt change, just the components of my body. Isnt that a perfect example that the nmber of pounds a girls weighs is not really a good indicator?

Well said!