There was never a debate on whether which of the two should have been drafted #1. In your mind, maybe. Or on Fox News. Everyone knew a year in advance that Mathews would be picked first (especially since he was a centre). There was a debate however on whom would get chosen next. It was going to be one of the two FInns (either Laine and his other countryman whose name escapes me). But Matthews clearly was the #1 choice projected and there was never debate about this once their professional NHL seasons got under way. Auston Matthews is already likely a shoe-in for the Hall of Fame and has barely three seasons of NHL hockey under his belt. Laine? Who knows. He could find his scoring touch again and be the next Phil Esposito in getting traded from the team that picked him & then traded him after 1-2 seasons and then become a top scorer.The debate as to whether Matthews or Patrik Laine should have been drafted #1 in 2016 finally seems to be over. Matthews has played 302 games and produced 316 points. Laine has played 319 games and produced 260 points. Mathews is a point a game player plus; Laine is not. Matthews also has more goals, which surprises me as I thought Laine would be the better goal scorer. But Matthews has just been the better player. 5 years later, we can finally say that Toronto got it right when they picked Matthews #1.