Toronto Maple Leafs: Brian Burke Needs to be Fired
Question for the class: Which Toronto team did better this weekend?
Initial Analysis: The Leafs were shut out but not blown away (at least not on the scoreboard - although they were blown away on the ice, as is CLEARLY pointed out in the excellent article posted by GHG in the No Truth Allowed thread. The article, by the way, was written by a TORONTO FAN!)
Secondary Analysis: The Argos were blown away but not shut out.
So, class, the question remains: Which Toronto team did better?
Please give three reasons for your decision. The response will be worth 20% of your final grade as a Toronto Sports Analyst.
Hello jc,
It was a great post by GHG...the results of the poll are interesting tho...41% (as of this post) say he should work through his contract expiration in 2014?
Have fun,
Jman
PS I am taking the liberty of posting it here for those who don;t want to switch threads:
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/523244-brian-burke-of-the-toronto-maple-leafs-needs-to-be-fired
Toronto Maple Leafs: Brian Burke Needs to be Fired
By Scott Weldon
Truculence and arrogance will apparently only take you so far.
Last night in Montreal, a Brian Burke-created team displayed a power play that made the Canadiens look like the mid-80 Oilers. Whatever you might think of this version of Les Glourieux, they are no 1980s Oilers. Their penalty kill doesn't feature Wayne Gretzky and Jarri Kurri or Mark Messier and Glenn Anderson. They are not on pace to score 36 short-handed tallies this year.
Against the Leafs, however, Montreal's penalty killers generated multiple chances, odd-man rushes and a short-handed goal. Jeff Halpern and Tomas Plekanec resembled modern-day Gretzkys and Lemieuxes.
A Montreal Canadiens team that has struggled around the 50 percent mark in the faceoff circle since the lockout won two-thirds of the faceoffs last night. Scott Gomez went an amazing 12 of 18, and Jeff Halpern won seven against Toronto. John Mitchell and Tyler Bozak, on the other hand, were a collective 5-of-17 for the Leafs.
Throw in defenseman Mike Komisarek's errant pass to Mike Cammalleri for the second Montreal goal and the game last night was almost a blanket condemnation of the moves Burke has made since he came to Toronto. Only Jonas Gustavsson, who played like a wall in net, looked like he was worth the money and time Brian Burke spent bringing him in.
I'm no Matt Stajan fan. He looks like a third-line checking center with some offensive skills. He was one of the players dealt for what Burke felt he had to have: yet another banger of a defenseman with a big point shot.
Stajan has not flourished in Calgary, but right now his 12 points in 16 games would have him looking like some sort of Davey Keon-Teeder Kennedy hybrid in Toronto. Mats Sundin was better at his worst than any of the three current Leaf centers.
When Burke became president and general manager of the Leafs back in November of 2008, no rational person expected rapid improvement in Toronto. This was obviously a case of needing to break the team down and rebuild it from the bottom up. This job was going to require patience from the organization, the fans and from the general manager himself.
While this was going on, the Chicago Blackhawks won the Stanley Cup and saddled the Maple Leafs with the longest current Stanley Cup-less streak in the NHL. The Leafs last won the Cup in 1967. The two teams with the next longest streak are expansion teams who joined the league for the 1968-69 season: the LA Kings and the St. Louis Blues.
Both of those teams are better than the Leafs right now and closer to winning a Cup. Worse still is the fact that both of those teams have more young talent ready to join and improve their teams than the Leafs do.
Burke could have dumped veterans, collected draft picks and slowly start to rebuild the Leafs. Teams with almost no leadership have managed over time to do just that. The Florida Panthers, New York Islanders and Atlanta Thrashers come to mind.
These organizations have suffered from indifferent and or incompetent management for years and yet they all have managed to stockpile young hockey talent. They all appear to be on the cusp of becoming teams that are interesting to watch.
The Leafs, unfortunately, under Burke's leadership, have regressed. What's worse is they haven't been rewarded for failure with any stockpiling of fresh young talent.
Ignoring the basic tenant of diminishing marginal returns, Burke has insisted on adding defenseman after defenseman after defenseman. Would the Leafs really be that much worse than they are now if they had run for the last couple of years with a defense of Kaberle, Schenn, White, Stralman, Colaiacovo and Finger?
Unfortunately, doing nothing does not feed the Burke ego. Anyone can do nothing or conversely no one can do nothing. Burke was compelled to put his mark on this team—to its detriment.
Brian Burke has cap-strung the Leafs. This miserable hockey team is paying a league maximum $55 million in salary according to capgeek.com. This is with Jeff Finger and his $3.5 million hidden in the minors. Next year the Leafs have $37 million dedicated to 11 players if Finger and his $3.5 million stay hidden. Hopefully, Jerry D'Amigo, Nazim Kadri and Carl Gunnarsson will be making quality contributions to the Leafs next year.
The Leafs cannot begin the search for a much-needed first-line center until they get their cap problems under control. The organization is praying for a huge bump in the salary cap next year to help bail them out. That does not seem like a high probability occurrence.
Burke needs to pay the price for this.
He traded two first-round draft picks and a second-rounder for talented restricted free agent Phil Kessel when he could have simply signed him for a first-round pick and two second-rounders.
Apparently, Burke is still obsessed with making some obscure point to former Oilers GM Kevin Lowe. Burke has refused to sign another team's restricted free agent because he felt using the rules in place in the collective bargaining agreement is wrong. He felt Lowe signing away his young star in Anaheim, Dustin Penner, somehow violated the rules of man and God.
The Toronto Maple Leafs are paying for Burke's hubris with yet another year without a first-round pick in the NHL Entry Draft. This is another year when the Leafs can't even begin the rebuilding process they need to go through to become the team every Leaf fan wants to see.
The fans want a good, exciting team that can compete year after year with a reasonable chance of winning a Cup. Th
e Leafs can start the process of creating that team at the 2012 NHL Entry Draft. Look for it to start to bear fruit around the 2016-17 season. This will probably be long after the LA Kings and the St. Louis Blues win their first Cups.
Brian Burke needs to be replaced long before that happens.