Beauty's and Dusty's
I am going to review Beauty's and Dusty's in one post together, because both are similar landmark Montreal breakfast diners that have been operating since the 1940s, and they are serving similar food in similar settings, with Dusty's having a larger physical space while Beauty's is apparently smaller and far more popular.
Beauty's, 93 Mont Royal Ouest, Le Plateau, Montreal, QC
Chercherfemmes insisted that when we came to Montreal in July for the Jazz Festival, the best meal he had on our 6 day trip was a breakfast he ate at local favorite Beauty's in Le Plateau, a Montreal landmark that was established in 1942. CCF also insisted I go back with him to experience the food there, as I had not been able to join him when he dined there in July.
Unlike the pretentious and haughty but trendy L'Avenue, Beauty's is a rather ordinary looking establishment that has the ambience of a typical diner, and in fact it probably has more cramped seating than most diners. The food, however, is indeed very good. CCF ordered his favorite dish there, the Challah French Toast, which he let me try. It is dipped in egg and not overcooked, which was a pleasant surprise. One reason I do not usually order French Toast when I eat out is that I find it is usually not prepared moist enough to suit my taste. That was definitely not the case with Beauty's Challah French Toast. However, I did find it to be lacking a bit in spicing, as I like cinnamon and nutmeg mixed in/on my French Toast. I understand that Challah is a naturally sweet bread and the culinary theory behind using it for French Toast may be one of minimalist preparation (meaning only soaking it in a beaten egg and leaving out the milk, sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg), but I prefer a bit more sweetness and spice even if Challah bread is used.
I ordered the plain buttermilk pancakes and they were quite good. For pancakes I have eaten in Montreal restaurants, they were certainly above average. And of significant importance, they were served with a generous, if not manly, bottle of maple syrup - which was certainly substantially more than the sissy-sized thimble containing a dollop of syrup that was served with pancakes at L'Avenue, which was barely sufficient to coat the top of half of one pancake. Undoubtedly, the owner of Beauty's is a man who is after Sapman's heart, because the waitress even asked me if we had enough maple syrup even AFTER bringing out this generous bottle. That is called good service!
The bacon served with my pancakes was crispy and tasty, and CCF reported that the sausages he had with his Challah French toast were also quite good. Our coffee was also very good, and the waitress was very attentive to refilling CCF and I as soon as we got low. The service at Beauty's was excellent.
One negative: the orange juice is vastly overpriced at $4 per glass. It is fresh squeezed, apparently, but nothing special and the glass is not particularly large.
On our way out, CCF and I noted a large group of young, English speaking girls, apparently McGill students, who were seated at several tables near the entrance.
Dusty's, 4510 Avenue du Parc, Montreal
Dusty's is a breakfast diner that is very similar to Beauty's and serving a very similar menu, but we found that the food was not quite as good as at Beauty's. Established in 1949, some 7 years after Beauty's opened, we could not help but wonder whether this resto was modeled after Beauty's. They have a larger physical space than Beauty's but the place somehow does not seem as busy on weekends as Beauty's is on a weekday.
I had the pancakes that were distinctly inferior to the pancakes I ordered at Beauty's. I believe they are using the same batter that they use for the crepes (not buttermilk based as at Beauty's) and the resulting pancakes were somewhat stiff and tasteless. Chercherfemmes ordered his favorite, Challah French Toast, which he let me try and while I thought it was actually better than the Challah French Toast at Beauty's, taste wise, CCF felt it was undercooked for his taste. Like Beauty's, we had an ample bottle of maple syrup at our table, therefore no need for Sapman to boycott either of these restos. L'Avenue might be another story.
Overall I feel Dusty's is serving a very average breakfast and I would not go there again. It does not stack up against Beauty's, though the menus of both restaurants are similar.