I think BBFS needs to be banned irrespectively of the consent. It is not only about these 2 individuals but the whole hobby community that would be endangered if it becomes frequent practice.
I know of many SPs who the moment it is asked by the client, he finds himself on their personal block list. Can't trust someone asking upfront for it, isn't going to try and pull an illegal move to get what he is asking for without concent.
And I am on the side of even if everyone is regularly tested. The one asking for no condom, is likely asking everyone, and I can't have faith that they haven't unknowingly caught something from someone who allows the practice. It is a gamble with my health I won't take. How can an SP be confident they don't have sti's, by getting regularly tested, and making sure things like this don't happen, and having the risks minimized as much as possible for how they want to run their business.
We are escorts, it is a livelihood, we are not hot wives, looking to play gambling games with our business or health. I say for those looking for condom free services, get a gf who is willing, and leave professionals out of the equasion.
I'm not nieve, and I know it does happen, and to each their own. I won't judge the SP who decides to do things differently, it is their right to do what they want. So long as it is their choice to do it and not have it done to them without concent. But I will say it is bothersome the number of men asking for it. I'm not a gambler, and my health and reputation is not something I am willing to start gambling with.