I did some research and it seems this all started with a coach named Al MacNeil, who coached the Habs in the early 1970s and actually won a Stanley Cup. He apparently butted heads with Henri Richard, who then publicly accused MacNeil of favoring anglophone players. Who knows if that was actually true, but the Henri Richard perception and accusation became reality. MacNeil was fired and then couldn't get a coaching job in the NHL. The perfectly bilingual Scotty Bowman was his replacement.
In my own mind no coach in the modern NHL, where the pressure to win is enormous and firings are common, is going to do anything other than play the best players that give the team the best chance to win. It doesn't even make sense to play favorites with players for any reason other than their hockey skills. So this notion of only hiring "French friendly" coaches is born of ignorance and stupidity of the realities of the league, which are that all coaches want to win, will play their best players in order to do so, and will be fired if they don't. If they are hiring a Francophone coach for the benefit of the media instead of his actual coaching acumen, that's an even stupider reason as I am guessing that most of the members of the Montreal media are bilingual. And if they aren't, then maybe they should be in that profession, which involves covering both Francophone and Anglophone players of many sports. There should be a zero tolerance for this kind of reverse bigotry and bias in sports.
In my own mind no coach in the modern NHL, where the pressure to win is enormous and firings are common, is going to do anything other than play the best players that give the team the best chance to win. It doesn't even make sense to play favorites with players for any reason other than their hockey skills. So this notion of only hiring "French friendly" coaches is born of ignorance and stupidity of the realities of the league, which are that all coaches want to win, will play their best players in order to do so, and will be fired if they don't. If they are hiring a Francophone coach for the benefit of the media instead of his actual coaching acumen, that's an even stupider reason as I am guessing that most of the members of the Montreal media are bilingual. And if they aren't, then maybe they should be in that profession, which involves covering both Francophone and Anglophone players of many sports. There should be a zero tolerance for this kind of reverse bigotry and bias in sports.
Last edited:




