EagerBeaver said:
I don't know that the 2004 and 2005 seasons were not the peak of Crisp's career and nor do you. Time will tell, but right now and for this season, I would rather have Damon as my everyday CF any day of the week and I am sure every major league GM would agree. By the ways you are quoting snippets of edited posts.
Crisp and Damon were both secured by their current teams for four years at the beginning of the 2006 season. Crisp, a 26 year old at the time, seemingly coming into his prime before seeing his season derailed by injury, would cost the Sox $23 M for the four years. Damon, at 32, would cost the Yanks $52 M over the same time period.
No doubt for the first 1 year and two weeks of this period, it appeared that the Yanks made the smarter move. Now, Crisp is coming to life, having beaten the Yanks and Mariano Rivera last Friday night, sparking a weekend sweep of the fading New Yorkers. Meanwhile, Damon over the same time period has seen his average fall from .300 to .242.
An article in this morning's NY Post reveals that the rapidly aging Damon is playing in agony, barely able to stand and walk, let alone play baseball. He's heading to Florida on Monday to visit his chiropracter in a last ditch effort to stay off the DL.
It's looking more and more like a lost season for the Yankees. Maybe the return of the elderly Mike Mussina and his 85 MPH fastball this coming week will give them the spark they need to get past the Tampa Bay Devil Rays in the standings.