Leafs Phenomenon
Jim McKenny witnessed both sides of what he calls the Toronto Maple Leafs phenomenon – for 12 seasons as a defenceman with the team from 1966-78, and then for many more years as a sportscaster covering the team for CITY-TV.
Like many of the ex-Leafs who teed it up as part of the NHL Alumni in Tuesday’s Canadian Tour Championship Pro-Am at Ambassador Golf Club, it’s a phenomenon for which they see no end in sight, no matter how many years the Leafs extend their current plight of non-playoff seasons, which is six in a row and counting, or their Stanley Cup drought, a 34-year skid.
“They talk about another (NHL) team coming into Toronto, and that wouldn’t hurt the Leafs at all,” said McKenny, 64. “Most of the hockey fans in Toronto are Leafs fans. They have real good American League hockey there, and they don’t draw flies. They have really good junior hockey with the (Mississauga St. Michael’s) Majors and the (Brampton) Battalion, and they don’t draw.
“It’s just a Leafs phenomenon that’s all around the city. People are crazy about the Leafs.”
Dave Hutchison, a Leafs defenceman from 1978-80, and again in 1983-84, compared the inflexible devotion of Leafs fans to those who support another famous lovable loser. “Have you ever heard of the Chicago Cubs?” Hutchison, 59, asked rhetorically. “Same thing. They’re real, true fans, and one day, we’re going to turn it around – I hope.”
Most of the former Leafs believe the aura that encompasses the Leafs faithful is one that’s ingrained into them almost from the time they leave the womb.
“Growing up and watching the games, that was who we watched, the Leafs,” said Leamington’s Pat Ribble, 57, who skated on the Leafs’ defence for 13 games during the 1979-80 season. “When I got traded there, it was such a big thrill for me. I was only there for 31 days, but it was a big part of my career, and I really enjoyed it.”
Hutchison remembers when the Leafs were dominant, and even though images of such greatness is only available today in grainy, black-and-white footage, to those who witnessed it, the pictures flow through their memory banks in vivid technicolor, and like some sage elders of the Leafs community, they pass on the tales of such lore to keep the dream alive for the current crop of long-suffering Leafs fans.
“When we were kids back in the 1960s, the Leafs won the Cup four times,” Hutchison said. “People from around that era, who would be their 50s now, were watching the Leafs then, and have an influence on their children. True Leafs fans are not jumping around and cheering for other teams when the Leafs aren’t doing well. And someday, we’re going to reap the benefits of this. And I hope, not too long from now.”
Even in Essex County, you won’t sway a Leafs fan to change their allegiance, even though one of the NHL’s most consistent franchises resides just across the border. “We’ve got Detroit that’s so close, and there’s still a lot of Leafs fans in the area,” Ribble said. “If you’re a fan, it’s tough to get off that bandwagon. I’m still a fan. I hope that they can come through.”
That overdose of Leafs coverage that is inflicted upon most every Canadian youngster may also be a double-edged sword, and play a role in Toronto’s troubles. “When I was with other teams – Los Angeles, Chicago – coming into Toronto, I always played my best game, because I knew that it was televised coast-to-coast, our family and friends were either in Toronto, or certainly watching it on TV,” Hutchison said. “People get up when they come into the rink. Toronto’s a tough place to win, because most of the other player’s emotions are running sky high when they come to Toronto to play.”
McKenny, also sees hope, but is a realist, and sees as well a significant hole at a key position in Toronto’s lineup. “They have a lot of talent, they have some good, young kids, they have a good back end, but for the last 100 years, the best teams have had good centres,” McKenny said. “The Leafs haven’t had centres since (Mats) Sundin left. They haven’t had a husky at centre, so there’s no one for the kids to learn from, because at the NHL level, you don’t learn from the coach, you learn from other players. It’s somebody who’s there in practice every day and they see what he does. They see what he does during the games.
“When (Darryl) Sittler broke in, they had (Dave) Keon and (Norm) Ullman, and Darryl got better real fast, just by watching those guys, what they did, how they positioned themselves, and the kind of effort they put in. The kids that are coming to the Leafs now have nobody to learn from. Perhaps (newcomers Tim) Connolly and (Matthew) Lombardi will fix that up.”
Regardless, McKenny thinks the Leafs have the ship headed in the proper direction for the first time in some years. “I think (Leafs GM Brian) Burke’s going about it in the right way,” McKenny said. “He did trade away a couple of draft choices for (Phil) Kessel, but I don’t think he’s going to do that anymore. I think they learned a hard lesson there.
“Kessel’s a hell of a hockey player, but the Leafs’ first-round picks are sometimes first overall, and there’s a big difference between a first-round picks and a first overall. There’s those first three picks, then there’s a big drop off after that. Those first three guys can really make a difference in your team. If the Leafs had (former Windsor Spitfire) Taylor Hall (of Edmonton) right now, they’d be in business. But they’re not in business. If (goaltender James) Reimer doesn’t play out of his mind again, they’re in big trouble.”
Not that it’s going to make anyone who bleeds blue-and-white look for a way out. “The Leafs phenomenon is still there, and if they ever had a winning team, it would just be crazy,” McKenny said.
Many of the Canadian Tour players were excited by the thought of teeing it up alongside some of their hockey heroes, a notion that made McKenny chuckle. “They’ll get over that in a real big hurry,” McKenny said. “Most of us will be chopping at it. (Gary) Leeman’s a good player and so’s Billy Derlago. I was good yesterday, but you never know about today.”
It was the hockey players who were hoping to pick up a few pointers on the links. “Hopefully, I can learn something, because I think I’m going to be out of my class,” Ribble said.
“I’m very excited to be able to play with a pro golfer,” Hutchison said. “I’m just going to try to learn everything that he has out there, or try to leave with some of it. Whether we win or not, we’re only here to help the charity (Hospice of Windsor) and have some fun.”
http://blogs.windsorstar.com/2011/08/23/ex-players-still-witness-leafs-phenomenon/