To be fair to the Red Sox pitching staff, the rest of the team ain't doing much either.
Pedroia is having one of his worse seasons, Crawford & Ellesbury were injured for a good part of the year but haven't done anything since they've been back. Speaking of Crawford, he'll likely undergo Tommy John surgery once the Red Sox throw-in the towel to their awful season. Adrian Gonzalez is having a good year, but for a first baseman, his power numbers are suspect. Middlebrooks is okay, but if i were the Red Sox, i'd rather have Youkilis playing in his spot. The shortstop position is once again the achilles' heel & there probably will be a new shortstop once again next season starting for the Red Sox. As for the catchers, they're nothing to write home about.
The outfield (incl. Ellesbury) is decent, but not much power. This season, the team's MVP has been Big Poppa, but he's been injured for the past few weeks & his absence has shown.
The only starter who's been effective has been Clay Bucholz, but he hasn't had much run support lately. As for the rest...Beckett, Lester, Melancon, Dice-K, Aceves....bums! The guy who cheated on his wife & dumped her as she was battling cancer hasn't thrown a pitch this season & he's been a disaster since they acquired him. I'm talking about John Lackie, of course. A world-class a-hole. Doubront has been okay, i must admit. That's about it.
Bobby Valentine will likely be fired after this season (or told to resign) and i'm not even certain if he had a fair shake. With all the injuries (okay, all the teams have had them, including the Yankees & Jays), the poor performances from the pitching staff, off-year by the players expected to lead....Pedroia, Crawford & Ellesbury....and most importantly, the loss of team leader & fan favorite Kevin Youikilis hurt the team. Let's not forget that the retirement of their catcher & long-time captain (and the lucky s.o.b. who screwed Heidi Watney) Jason Varitek certainly didn't help matters when leadership would have been greatly needed on this badly dysfunctional team. Adrian Gonzalez isn't a leader. Big Poppa could be, but he doesn't want to be & will likely play elsewhere next season.
Sad.