p.s. Note that Phil Kessel is a superstar & has been a top 10 points and goal scorer over the past 2 seasons. And he just turned 26 today. He's just entering his prime & will be a force for years to come. Also consider the fact the Leafs were only able to re-sign some players because of Kessel's presence in Toronto.
1. I would not call Kessel a superstar. I'd
very grudgingly concede "star" (at the very
lowest level of that designation) but definitely NOT "superstar". I would reserve "superstar" (active players only) for the likes of Crosby, Ovechkin, Datsyuk, Malkin, Brodeur (more for his BODY of work over two decades than for his CURRENT work), Stamkos, and St. Louis. Once you get past that ELITE group, you have many "stars" such as Zetterberg, Alfredsson, Iginla, Toews, Kane, Giroux, Quick, etc....but if you start calling too many people "superstars" the term becomes meaningless. Phil is a decent offensive player but he's never even had a 40 goal season and he's
well below a point a game for his career. Decent speed, decent shot but far too reluctant to pay the price and get his hands dirty. Also, as a defensive player, let's just say that guys like Datsyuk and Bergeron will never have to worry about him being competition for the Selke! He doesn't hit, he doesn't block shots, and he sure as hell doesn't fight (we're not counting stickwork!). So what we have is a one-dimensional player who's a little - but not a lot - above average in basic offensive skills. All in all, I think even calling him a "star" might be generous.
2. You say that "the Leafs were only able to re-sign some players because of Kessel's presence...." but (first) that doesn't make much difference since players are looking out for number one and go where they can get security and $$$$ (or in the case of veterans like Alfie or Iginla to a place where they think they can finally win a Cup) and (second) the Leafs will NOT be able to re-sign some players BECAUSE Phil's contract is eating up so much cap space. Also, the fact that Carolina gave a ridiculous contract to Semin doesn't mean that the Leafs had to give a ridiculous contract to Kessel.