Rangers’ answer to Bautista bat flip was gutless
To wait seven months after the flip, to wait for the final game of the 2016 season series, in Bautista’s final at-bat, was just wrong.
by Richard Griffin, Baseball columnist
Matt Bush is an idiot. Rougned Odor is a punk. Jose Bautista is an old-school baller that plays the game right. John Gibbons is spontaneous and genuine. Jesse Chavez understands what needs to be done. And even though the Rangers may believe they evened the score for the bat flip by Bautista in Game 5 of the ALDS, I guarantee the Texas veteran players don’t feel good about it.
There have been thousands of slides at second base in major-league baseball history that were more dangerous and reckless than Bautista’s takeout at second base of the Rangers’ Odor on Sunday afternoon. It’s part of the respected history of the game. It’s how things are settled and self-regulated on the field and have been for years. You hit me, I slide in hard. But 21st century political correctness and a knee-jerk MLB need to feel it is protecting its players has somehow made the game more dangerous.
There will be fines and possible suspensions to the Blue Jays and Rangers, but MLB needs to take a huge amount of the responsibility in the matter. The new rules give players a false sense of safety — until they’re broken. Whether this makes the Jays a tighter team moving forward is yet to be seen.
This is the first year of the slide rule at second base. Begin your slide early, keep your feet down and don’t slide past the bag. Middle infielders feel somehow protected. So when someone doesn’t abide by the rules, does that mean they can feel assaulted and can respond with a punch to the face?
Under current rules, the slide by Bautista and the wide throw that resulted was an automatic double play. He left his feet late and slid straight over, but well past the bag. This was a much easier call than the Bautista slide in Tampa that ended a loss in April. Here, he was making a point in the old-school, traditional baseball manner, without intent to injure but in response to being hit on purpose. Bautista knew the automatic call was coming — but not the sucker-punch right hand from Odor.
In the past, what Bautista did would have been an acceptable response to being drilled by the Rangers’ right-hander Bush, with a 96 miles-per-hour fastball. He knew the Rangers were still upset by his emotional three-run homer and bat-flip in Game 5 of the 2015 ALDS at the Rogers Centre.
But the Rangers had always publicly downplayed any lingering animosity that was still there. To wait seven months and one day after the flip, to wait for the final game of the 2016 season series, in Bautista’s final at-bat was just wrong. After Bautista had sent his hard-slide message in response to being drilled, Odor’s idiotic response was to wheel quickly and physically assault Bautista, beginning with a two-hand push to the chest, followed by a sucker punch to the right side of the face that sent helmet and glasses flying and an overhand with the fielding glove that was still on his left hand.
At least in hockey, players drop their gloves to signal a fight and as an opponent you then know to expect that punches will be thrown. Odor’s answer to the slide and the fact of the Rangers waiting until the final game of the season series and the final at-bat was in Bautista’s words “cowardly.” And he’s right. Odor was not available for comment and Bush’s response was “no comment.”
Whether the 30-year-old Bush took it upon himself to exact revenge on Bautista for the Game 5 bat-flip from the 2015 ALDS, for whether someone in the Rangers’ dugout suggested that he do it, Bush was clearly the wrong man to settle the score for the Rangers. He wasn’t there in ’15.
Why not Sam Dyson, the pitcher that served up the Bautista bomb? He had plenty of opportunities, facing Bautista twice in the series in Toronto. In fact, the Rangers had spent six games denying that there was any lingering feelings about Game 5, then in the final game of the season series, not meeting for another year — unless it’s the playoffs again — they threw at Bautista.
“To me it was gutless,” Jays’ manager John Gibbons said. And he’s right.
No one has ever suggested that Bush thinks things through, logically. At the moment Bautista hit his game-winning blast last October, Bush was serving out the end of a 39-month sentence in Florida for a hit-and-run, injuring a 72-year-old man, knocking him off his motorcycle. He was accused of DUI and leaving the scene, and pleaded no contest.
Do the other Rangers feel this is the guy to settle the score for them in what is the oldest of baseball traditions, taking care of things on the field?
A first-overall pick of the Padres 12 years ago, the weekend series against the Jays was his first taste of MLB action.
Bush was convicted in 2004 for felony assault and misdemeanour trespass. He was involved in another incident in ’09 in which he allegedly beat a high school lacrosse player with a golf club and then an incident in which he allegedly assaulted and screamed at a woman at a party that resulted in the Blue Jays releasing him in ’09. But Bush claims he is a new man, that after serving time, it won’t happen again.
Nevertheless, he was not the right man to throw at Bautista.
Who knows. It may bring the Jays closer as a team. Kevin Pillar raced out to confront Odor. Gibbons came back out on the field after being ejected earlier and went after the Rangers’ manager Jeff Banister, which will not be looked at well by MLB. Coach DeMarlo Hale confronted Prince Fielder. Then the next inning, Jesse Chavez drilled Fielder in his ample right thigh and walked slowly off the field with what he knew was an automatic ejection as the benches cleared for a second time.
The Jays lost the battle 7-6, but they are hoping that eventually the 2016 war can be won. There is nothing for the Jays to be ashamed of in this fight. But the Rangers? That’s another story.
Rangers gutless