Here's a couple of scouts reactions to the game in Trenton last night. Note that none of these scouts work for the Red Sox or Yankees.
“If they’re both the same, I want Buchholz starting for me right now,” a National League scout said. “You know there is more to Rocket, but this kid had better stuff tonight.”
“I would have more confidence in this kid (Buchholz) starting a major league game tomorrow than the other guy (Clemens),” said one American League scout in attendance for Clemens’ second minor league tune-up for the New York Yankees, a start for the Double-A Thunder in their 4-3, 10-inning loss to the Portland Sea Dogs. “We need one game to win the division and you’re giving me a choice between starting (Buchholz) or Clemens, I’m taking (Buchholz) off of what I saw tonight.”
“I think you’re going to see a lot of 2-2 counts, a lot of 3-2 counts. I don’t see (Clemens) getting deep into games,” the scout said. “Every fastball is going to be away, but I don’t see him blowing anybody away. I think you’re going to see him throwing 80-90 pitches through five (innings). I don’t think he’s going to have a lot of quick-pitch innings, and not getting through six much at all. He will be OK, but not the guy.”
Buchholz, meanwhile, topped out at 95 mph while impressing with a curveball Sea Dogs manager Arnie Beyeler described before the game as “a (Josh) Beckett curve.”
“This guy has great stuff,” the scout said. “He’s got a good fastball and just a hammer of a curve. You can see how he punches guys out. This guy can get some K’s, whereas I don’t see Clemens striking out a lot of guys. I don’t think (Clemens) gets a strikeout an inning, but (Buchholz) could pitch in the big leagues right now. Right now, if you’re looking at both of them, all things being equal, I’m taking (Buchholz).”