Must agree with the Beaver, Korbel. Through 5, Matsuzaka, allowing 3 earned, was slightly less than mediocre. After quickly retiring two in the sixth, he walked two before leaving. Regardless of the fact that he left before they scored, they were charged to him.
At this point, Matsuzaka has an ERA of 4.48, exactly league average. I regard that as a disappointment. My sense, however, is that with a year to adjust to the MLB workload, he will only improve next year.
The Sox are being much more cautious with the workload of the 23 year old Buchholz than are the Spankees with that of 20 year old Hughes or 21 year old Kennedy. I only hope that the Sox give Buchholz a significant role in the post-season, the time of year when A-Rod turns into Mario Mendoza.