It seems like the whole island should be one united political municipal entity.
You're far from the only one to think that. In fact, ex-Mayor Jean Drapeau launched in 1960 with Lucien Saulnier the idea "Une île, une ville" ("One island, one city"). It never materialized and when Mayor Bourque tried to ressuscitate the idea with the govt of Quebec circa 2000, it was a disaster... Mostly because people are emotionally very attached to their community, and don't want to give control over to "central City"... a bit when like the states/provinces don't want the federal govt to decide for them. Add to that the language component, English communities were wary of amalgamating politically with a mostly French city... and the fact that Bourque had help from a PQ government.. It was
a big mess.
It makes a lot of sense, but efforts to implement it backfired spectacularly, so I'm not sure what they should do about it. After the 2000-2004 fiasco, nobody wants to open that Pandora's box.
Personally, I am fully supportive of Projet Montreal's incline toward giving boroughs more power, because it seem to me that every time things are controlled from City Hall, instead of uniformly doing things right accross boroughs, things are uniformly done wrong accross the board. If we don't have a solution to that, we might as well decentralize.
As for Griffintown, it really should be its own riding and not part of 3 others. I find it odd that this neighborhood should be part of 3 separate precincts.
Perhaps. Probably gonna be eventually. For the moment, i think Griffintown is very shitty. A complete mess, only condos, no community, terrible lack of services. It lacks two things in particular: life, and soul.
Regarding Plante, I heard that she is an extreme leftist
When it appeared clear to the Coderre team that they were going to lose (they probably had internal polls indicating so),
they went in full fearmongering mode and sent AnieSamson (a well-known liar whose resignation was asked for the way she conducted the pitbull debacle, and who got the asskicking she deserved Sunday) and tried to portray Plante and Projet Mtl as "radical leftists" and "extremists".
They're not, and good on Montrealers for not listening that non-sense. Yes, they have Quebec solidaire supporters in their rank, they also have HEC students, they ran a business owner in Hochelaga that is now in office, I personally know small businesses owners who support them. It is a broad coalition at this point. You can't elect extreme leftists (or extreme right-wingers for that matter) in Montreal. You have to go toward the center, or you are condemned to the political fringe. They do have a left slant though, and the way they deal with unions will be something to keep an eye on.