Hello all,
Looking at the injury factor, the injury situation was persistent and decisive, among other critical factors. Every creditable sports source has said the Sox had the worst injury conditions in the majors this year. The team at one point had no more than one starting player in the lineup for over a week, lost an MVP...a third place MVP ballot player...3 starting pitchers...every starting hitter except the DH...and the top two catchers. No team could endure that many injuries and win the toughest division in the MLB regardless of any performance factors.
Regarding any allusion about the Sox in the Eastern AL division...EB you are the biggest ARROGANT BS ARTIST ON ANY BOARD. That's all I have to say on that.
Doc, I do respect your opinion here. But I think if the Sox got the reasonably expected performances out of their players, while facing no worse than the league average kind of injuries in number and type, and the other teams faced the same conditions, I think it's a magnificent three-way race right to the end. Had all players performed to average reasonable expectations the Sox end up being very close through 162 games even despite the injuries and considering the incredible contributions of many heroic substitutes. But as it was, the totality of injuries were decisive.
If reasonable expectations had been achieved such as: Beckett and Lackey with a 13-15 wins each, Delcarmen and Okajima being decent middle relief help, Papelbon being just what he was the year before and we are right there. Remember even with the gross under-performance of Beckett, the decline of and often lousy middle relief, disappointing closing pitching, a catcher who has one of the worst defensive records in the MLB, and an endless slew of injuries...yet we were just 3 games out at one point around the All-Star break.
What do you expect.
Cheers,
Merlot