Honest NFL fans,
NFL Power Rankings: 30 Greatest QBs Of All-Time
http://nflspinzone.com/2015/03/06/nfl-power-rankings-30-greatest-qbs-time/2/
30. Ken Stabler (1970-84)
29. Bobby Layne (1948-62)
28. Ben Roethlisberger (2004-Active)
27. YA Tittle (1948-64)
26. Warren Moon (1984-2000)
25. Dan Fouts (1973-87)
24. Joe Namath (1965-77)
23. George Blanda (1949-75)
22. Len Dawson (1957-75)
21. Sammy Baugh (1937-52)
20. Sid Luckman (1939-50)
19. Bob Griese (1967-80)
18. Terry Bradshaw (1970-83)
4 Championships
68 Winning %
3 Time All-Star
70.9 QB Rating
27,989 Passing Yards
212-210 TD/INT
Terry Bradshaw is only one of three quarterbacks who have won four Super Bowls. His abilities as a leader cannot be matched.
The talent that surrounded him though cannot be ignored. His team featured the best defense in the history of the NFL which was always the catalyst for their so many successes.
Bradshaw’s stats do not stand out, and for that he cannot be considered in the top 10. He’s a great quarterback, but partly a bus driver as well.
Not all was rosy for Bradshaw in Pittsburgh though. As the number-one overall draft selection in 1970, Bradshaw struggled mightily as a rookie.
17. Norm Van Brocklin (1949-60)
16. Jim Kelly (1986-96)
0 Championships
63 Winning %
5 Time All-Star
84.4 QB Rating
35,467 Passing Yards
237-175 TD/INT
There are a few guys on this list that would be thrust into a better ranking if they could’ve just broke through once. If it hadn’t been for a “wide right” in Super Bowl XXV, Jim Kelly would be perceived differently.
Fearless leader of the K-Gun, Kelly’s passing wizardry was amazing. If he just played in the NFL in 1984-85 instead of with the Houston Gamblers in the USFL, Kelly’s stats would be even more impressive.
15. Troy Aikman (1989-2000)
14. Kurt Warner (1998-2009)
13. Aaron Rodgers (2005-Active)
1 Championship
67.9 Winning %
4 Time All-Star
106 QB Rating
28,578 Passing Yards
226-57 TD/INT
Just take a look at that career passer rating of 106. Simply ridiculous.
Sure, Aaron Rodgers plays in the pass-happy era of the NFL, but the back of his football card simply cannot be explained. He’s probably the best quarterback to ever feel pressure around him, navigate through the pocket and throw a dime on the run.
At only 31-years of age, Rodgers has a ton more damage to do on this list.
12. Steve Young (1985-99)
11. Fran Tarkenton (1961-78)
10. Bart Starr (1956-71)
5 Championships
64 Winning %
4 Time All-Star
80.5 QB Rating
24,718 Passing Yard
152-138 TD/INT
Before there was Rodgers, there was Bart Starr and his dominant Green Bay Packers teams of the 1960’s.
Vince Lombardi swore by him as a leader and he delivered in the most clutch of ways as the MVP of the first two Super Bowls. And no football fans, the Super Bowl wasn’t the first championship in NFL history. Rather Starr won three NFL Championships prior to the merger.
Starr will forever be remembered as one of the greatest leaders to ever play the game.
9. Brett Favre (1991-2010)
8. John Elway (1983-98)
7. Roger Staubach (1969-79)
6. Peyton Mannning (1998-Active)
1 Championship
69.9 Winning %
14 Time All-Star
97.5 QB Rating
69,691 Passing Yards
530-234 TD/INT
Simply put, Peyton Manning is the greatest NFL regular season player of all-time. The consistency week in, week out that he proved with the Indianapolis Colts and Denver Broncos was remarkable.
It lead to epic seasons of not once breaking the single-season touchdown record, but twice (2004, 2013).
He is now the all-time leader in passing touchdowns and is on the brink of becoming the yards leader.
While playoff success has eluded Manning, his one Super Bowl keeps him safe on this list.
5.Dan Marino (1983-99)
0 Championships
60 Winning %
9 Time All-Star
86.4 QB Rating
61,361 Passing Yards
420-252 TD/INT
In the 1990’s Dan Marino broke almost every conceivable passing record Tarkenton once held. He was Favre and Manning before they came around, and he did it during the 80’s which proved to be a much tougher era for quarterbacks to navigate through.
Only Namath rivals the actual passing arm Marino possessed.
Unfortunately, his only Super Bowl appearance came as a rookie and when the NFC was far superior to the weaker AFC. He broke records without ever having a single Hall of Fame weapon on his team.
His quick release alone should have a separate wing in Canton.
4. Tom Brady (2000-Active)
4 Championships
77.3 Winning %
10 Time All-Star
95.9 QB Rating
53,258 Passing Yards
392-143 TD/INT
If the 2014-15 NFL Playoffs proved one thing to us, it’s that while Manning owns the regular season, New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady owns the postseason.
No quarterback and coach tandem is better at executing a specific strategy-filled gameplan than Brady and Belichick. Brady’s attitude lends to such characteristics as fiery, fierce, emotional, yet calm.
When John Madden suggested the young quarterback kneel on the ball in his first Super Bowl appearance against the St. Louis Rams, he did the exact opposite and drove them to an Adam Vinatieri championship winning kick.
His winning percentage is second best on this list as he slowly creeps up the leader-board in many categories.
It is very conceivable that when it’s all said and done, Brady could top this list.
3. Otto Graham (1946-55)
7 Championships (in 10 years)
79 Winning %
7 Time All-Star
86.6 QB Rating
23,584 Passing Yards
174-135 TD/INT
If winning is associated with Brady, then dominating is associated with Otto Graham.
Seven championships is what Graham brought to the city of Cleveland during his short 10-year career, and his winning percentage of 79 is absurd. Don’t be fooled by looking at these stats and shaking your head, his 23,584 passing yards and 174 touchdowns was considered insane during those days.
Much like Luckman in Chicago, Graham was another converted college tailback. His amazing operating of the Cleveland running game was just as impressive as his passing accolades.
2. Johnny Unitas (1956-73) (a personal favorite)
3 Championships
65 Winning %
10 Time All-Star
78.2 QB Rating
40,239 Passing Yards
290-253 TD/INT
The mystique of Johnny Unitas is enough to get any old-time football head going nuts, especially considering he was a measly nine-round pick in the NFL Draft.
During a time that featured rugged defense and dominating running (Jim Brown), Unitas quickly rose to the top as the best signal caller of all-time. Unitas was the winning quarterback in the 1958 NFL Championship that most consider “The Greatest Game Ever Played.”
“Johnny U” was an NFL MVP three-times while taking home All-NFL recognition six times.
1. Joe Montana (1979-94)
4 Championships
71 Winning %
8 Time All-Star
92.3 QB Rating
40,551 Passing Yards
273-139 TD/INT
Joe Cool took once glance at John Candy in the stands and proceeded to drive the team on an epic 11-play, 93-yard drive that still ranks as one of the best in Super Bowl history. It was of course Super Bowl XXIII where he found John Taylor on a slant in the end-zone.
A big factor in ranking Montana over Brady includes this drive. Montana’s drive ended in a touchdown while Brady’s two ended in field goals while the game was tied. Another factor is the eras that each played in.
Montana finished with four championships in total. He still ranks 13th all-time in yards and 11th in touchdowns. He did it in an era that allowed his receivers to be mugged at times and where real punishment was dished out on the field general, instead of a defender’s hand glancing a quarterback’s helmet yielding a 15-yard flag.
Cheers,
Merlot